Steve Wan | 06/04/2011 07:42:00 |
131 forum posts 3 photos | Hi guys,
I read that this invention of mass production for lathes in WW1 were possible. Concrete was used then as cast iron was in short supply. With this in mind, has anyone tried making his lathe/mill in concrete cast? Though concrete is good for making the machine stable from vibration, what about the thin walls and cracks will occur in due course. If anyone has done this approach, please share your exciting moments as I would like to give it a go one day.
Steve |
Clive Hartland | 06/04/2011 09:32:56 |
![]() 2929 forum posts 41 photos | A composite material might be very good for vibration damping in a job like this!
Some concrete mixes have fibres mixed in to make them lighter and stronger.
They would have to be cast in a jig and any bedways would need to be attached during this process.
I would think they may be very large machines and not bench type machines where cast iron and steel would be far better.
An interesting project if you want to machine something like an aircraft spar about 60' plus.
Clive |
Gordon W | 06/04/2011 09:58:47 |
2011 forum posts | I can remember seeing huge lathes in shipyards, for m/cing prop shafts ,I guess. These had big mass concrete head and tail stock, with steel bedway for the cutting tools, but I think to big for you. |
PekkaNF | 06/04/2011 11:27:21 |
96 forum posts 12 photos | Hello,
I bet you are thinkking of casting normal rebar reinforced concrete structure.
Concrete can take a lof of compression and it is good in dampping among other properties. Although It shrinks much with the time. You could age it naturally before milling pads, you could try to find more stable concrete or you could make provisions for shrinkage.
Because of shrinkage it would be a bad idea to pour concrete inside of the metal "tube", far better idea would be to have iron structure outside and have concrete body on compression. Concrete really is pretty bad to machine, you need metal pads and plates that you can skim and level after curing and agigng the structure. In the industry often machine base plates are jacked straight over concrete sructure and then voids are filled with injection "epoxy". I'm pretty sure it has some filler.
I chekked some injection concretes that are available at the hardware stores, they expand first to counteract shrinkage. I'm not sure if this leads to more stable body.
See here some good info about frames and concrete core damping.
Then there is polymer concrete. This is rather different animal. If you think of a minimum possible amont of epoxy and maximum amount of rock in differet particle sizes - you are close.
This approach needs better process control and also materials tend to be more expensive. For a professional builder benefits are clear: More stable and fast production i.e. no concrete type of shrinkage.
Have fun. I have been toying with an idea of trying this to a small grinding machine.
PekkaNF Edited By David Clark 1 on 06/04/2011 17:14:13 |
Ian S C | 06/04/2011 14:04:40 |
![]() 7468 forum posts 230 photos | Some one (it may have been Tubal Cain), wrote of concrete lathe benches as being ideal for a good foundation for any bench type lathe (or Mill) think it was in ME. The bench would be easy to level, before mounting the machine. Ian S C |
GoCreate | 06/04/2011 15:29:40 |
![]() 387 forum posts 119 photos | Just a bit off topic but this thread reminded me of the remains of WW1 or WW2 concrete boats laying in a horbour near where I lived as a child. My grandmother assured me they did float. So concrete has more uses than you would think.
Nigel |
Richard Parsons | 06/04/2011 17:30:14 |
![]() 645 forum posts 33 photos | Steve Yes you can make almost anything out of concrete. The moulds for the Mosquito fuselages were made of it. The Mulberries were, some yachts still are and all of the tracks in the Paris underground –the Metro- still are. The trains have rubber tires which run on steel plates bolted to the concrete track way. The stations stink of hot rubber. I once worked in a factory which built machines. Each time a new machine was started its concrete building base was ground dead flat before the machine was started. The real problems with concrete are the mix and the ‘green’ period. That is the time before the concrete develops its full strength which in some cases can be months. There can also be a problem with heat which can affect crystal growth. Yes you have got 'advert incurtion' again!
Edits 1 & 2
Interesting I have just posted and the 'advert incurtion' has disaeared.
If you are getting it try pressing PF12 in Edit mode it gives you the message as a full page no ads. To return to 'normal' press PF 12 again.
Edited By Richard Parsons on 06/04/2011 17:34:18 Edited By Richard Parsons on 06/04/2011 17:35:34 |
wheeltapper | 06/04/2011 18:47:49 |
![]() 424 forum posts 98 photos | I see David has edited the offending links, so advert incursion go away now ![]() I wish posters would learn how to shorten their links. Roy |
Dave Tointon | 06/04/2011 22:41:15 |
49 forum posts | Many years ago I worked in a sugar mill where we had a home-made lathe for machining the cane crushing rollers. They were about a metre in diameter, 3 metres long, in some sort of cast steel. Th lathe was made of concrete with welded steel frame. It worked a treat, albeit slowly.
Regards
Dave Tointon |
Ian S C | 07/04/2011 12:56:17 |
![]() 7468 forum posts 230 photos | I don't know if its still done very much here now, but 20-30yrs agoconcrete was being used to build fishing boats and yatchs, now glass or carbon fiber over a sandwich of foam or balsa wood is common, while the fishing boats are aluminium, and often jet powered. Ian S C |
Weldsol | 07/04/2011 18:08:19 |
74 forum posts | All the big column and booms 7m high x 9 m reach for welding, we used to supply for the wind turbine towers for offshore had concrete bases and all the attachment points for the slew ring 20 off 16mm and rail mount bogies were cast in.
We never had a problem and they all seemed very stable on dimensions
I think with some fore thought you could acheive a good base for a lathe. The main problem would be machining all the mounting point to get them level (depending on the size of lathe)
One last point we were not allowed to drill and and use expanding fixings i,e, rawlplug as it could be a stress point that had not been calculated for
Paul |
ady | 08/04/2011 00:32:20 |
612 forum posts 50 photos | Yes you can make almost anything out of concrete. The moulds for the
Mosquito fuselages were made of it. The Mulberries were, some yachts
still are... The mulberries used up so much concrete they stripped Britain of concrete for other war uses. The Hoover dam was built in rectangular blocks because a single pour would have taken 125 years to harden. Edited By ady on 08/04/2011 00:39:45 |
Richard Parsons | 08/04/2011 09:56:02 |
![]() 645 forum posts 33 photos | Yes they used much concrete as we built two. These were full sized harbours each able to support and supply armies. One was for the Brits and the other was for the U.S. of A. Unfortunately one of them was a total loss after the first really good Atlantic storm, so the second one had to carry the whole load. This ‘bottle neck’ which led to supply shortages, and caused a slowing down of the war in Western Europe. as it gave the enemy time to consolidate. The remains of the second one are still there to this day (nearly 70 years later) Which one was lost and why? A few clues, which lot did not bother to train the builders? Who placed a senior officer, who could not read engineering drawings, in charge and who threw away the instruction manuals? If the designers/builders give you 24 anchors each with two wires attached do they mean you to use them all? And finally who just took the bits and pieces higgledy-piggeldy (for speed) and not in the order they were laid out. You guess who. |
Bill Pudney | 08/04/2011 23:12:47 |
622 forum posts 24 photos | We seem to have wandered off the thread a bit. Rather than concrete I would have thought that an epoxy based polymer would be the way to go. Hardinges use has already been mentioned, but there are several others. There has even been a couple of articles in MEW about using an epoxy based vibration damper in Chinese mills. This would be a start in reading. About the Mulberry harbour stuff up, I gave up guessing when I got married 36 years ago, so come on who was it???? cheers Bill Pudney |
Gray62 | 09/04/2011 00:05:22 |
1058 forum posts 16 photos | Pure cast concrete will not withstand the stresses and vibration induced by normal rotary machining processes. I believe the structural materiel you are aluding to is more akin to an epoxy granite based compound. This is often used in industry to produce high strength, highly stable machine bases and superstructures. There is a great deal of science in selecting the correct grade of epoxy resin and granite,silicon and quartz fillers that make up a suitable tructural compound for the intended purpose. I have used some fairly crude epoxy granite based fillers to fill out the voids in the cast base and column of a low cost mini mill which has made significant improvements to the rigidity of the machine. I suggest googling epoxy granite fillers and also take a look at http://www.cnccookbook.com/CCMillEpoxyFill.htm , there is some useful info there. I based my mix on the info on this site and it has worked very well. One thing to bear in mind when building anything purely from an epoxy granite based compound, is that you will need to build a rigid mould and be able to vibrate the entire mould in order to compact the fillers so that teh epoxy is purely a bonding agent. The epoxy has little structural strength, it is the varying grades of filler that provide the strength and rigidity, in much the same way as traditional concrete does however, epoxy has greater long term stability properties than cast concrete. |
Steve Wan | 09/04/2011 05:29:51 |
131 forum posts 3 photos | Hi Guys,
Thank you so much for the vast information and also generated so much interest here
![]() I have learnt alot and will be prepared to experiment filling cast voids with epoxy granite instead of purely concrete.
First will look out any supplier here, I guess the epoxy granite is widely used for housing the washing basin in the kitchen nowadays...so should be easy to find.
Steve |
Stub Mandrel | 09/04/2011 19:29:05 |
![]() 4318 forum posts 291 photos 1 articles | Back in the 70's I knew someone who was researching 'light concrete' at UWIST. They made a concrete canoe and he demonstrated a 6" cube of ncrete that floated. Neil |
Baz | 09/04/2011 21:57:02 |
1033 forum posts 2 photos | If my memory serves me correctly, the Hardinge CNC lathe using concrete was the Talent range. These were slant bed machines as opposed to their CHNC range which were similar to the HLVH series. |
Richard Parsons | 10/04/2011 09:52:36 |
![]() 645 forum posts 33 photos | The Mulberry 'A' Off Omaha beach. |
Douglas Johnston | 10/04/2011 09:59:10 |
![]() 814 forum posts 36 photos | one of the best ways to mount a lathe or mill on a wooden bench is to place a concrete slab on top of the bench using a bonding agent between the concrete and wooden top. The concrete should be a decent thickness, made from a thick paving slab or cast in place.
By this means you ensure there is no distortion in the machine if the wooden structure moves slightly over time. There is probably some damping benefit as well when the machine is solidly bolted to the concrete. |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.