lfoggy | 30/05/2019 22:40:58 |
![]() 231 forum posts 5 photos | Is it even possible to buy a new manual lathe today of this quality? |
David Standing 1 | 30/05/2019 23:11:48 |
1297 forum posts 50 photos |
Yep
|
Hopper | 31/05/2019 03:49:34 |
![]() 7881 forum posts 397 photos | Just a matter of money. If a new Myford is 5,000 quid, what price a shiny new Colchester? |
DC31k | 31/05/2019 07:06:11 |
1186 forum posts 11 photos | Posted by Hopper on 30/05/2019 12:46:45:
Best part though is cleaning those casting mould boxes by spraying kerosene with a blow gun, then casually lighting a piece of paper from the (very) nearby blowtorch and flashing it all off. LOL.
Would it have been kerosene? He says 'spirit carrier', so much more likely alcohol-based. Paraffin ignited in that manner would be rather smoky. What interests me is all the gold-coloured machines they use to make the lathes. Did they paint them up specially for the film or was every machine in the factory that colour? |
Michael Gilligan | 31/05/2019 07:44:25 |
![]() 23121 forum posts 1360 photos | Wonderful film, Alan Everything from casting through to the Talyrond inspection Can you imagine what it must have cost, to provision that facility !?! MichaelG.
|
Andrew Evans | 31/05/2019 09:31:33 |
366 forum posts 8 photos | Thanks for the link Alan. I think they must have painted all the machinery in gold just for the film - it looks too perfect otherwise. Andy |
Journeyman | 31/05/2019 09:45:01 |
![]() 1257 forum posts 264 photos | Posted by Hopper on 31/05/2019 03:49:34:
Just a matter of money. If a new Myford is 5,000 quid, what price a shiny new Colchester? Don't know about that Colchester but a new Harrison M300 which is about the same spec will cost around £15,000 (+VAT) which if you say it quickly doesn't sound too bad. Colchester, Harrison and Clausing are all part of the 600 group and all their new lathes seem to sport the Colchester livery and logo. John Edited By Journeyman on 31/05/2019 09:54:05 |
David Standing 1 | 31/05/2019 10:07:05 |
1297 forum posts 50 photos | Posted by Journeyman on 31/05/2019 09:45:01:
Posted by Hopper on 31/05/2019 03:49:34:
Just a matter of money. If a new Myford is 5,000 quid, what price a shiny new Colchester? Don't know about that Colchester but a new Harrison M300 which is about the same spec will cost around £15,000 (+VAT) which if you say it quickly doesn't sound too bad. Colchester, Harrison and Clausing are all part of the 600 group and all their new lathes seem to sport the Colchester livery and logo. John Edited By Journeyman on 31/05/2019 09:54:05
Today's Student and M300 are badge engineered clones of each other. As John says, a new M300/Student (long bed) is around £20k all in. Mine is all the lathe I will ever need |
Stuart Bridger | 31/05/2019 10:40:38 |
566 forum posts 31 photos | Date on of the film? Any more clues? |
SillyOldDuffer | 31/05/2019 10:47:25 |
10668 forum posts 2415 photos | Posted by DC31k on 31/05/2019 07:06:11:
Posted by Hopper on 30/05/2019 12:46:45:
Best part though is cleaning those casting mould boxes by spraying kerosene with a blow gun, then casually lighting a piece of paper from the (very) nearby blowtorch and flashing it all off. LOL.
Would it have been kerosene? He says 'spirit carrier', so much more likely alcohol-based. Paraffin ignited in that manner would be rather smoky. What interests me is all the gold-coloured machines they use to make the lathes. Did they paint them up specially for the film or was every machine in the factory that colour? I liked the roll-up fag the moulder had tucked behind his ear! Some of the close-ups show the gold paint was sprayed a little carelessly. Pretty sure it was added to help the colour photography along and to direct our eyes to the important bits. Interesting that the film emphasised that the lathe was 'inexpensive' and it highlighted a number of go-faster high accuracy production methods (no scraping). At the same time they were still using labour intensive methods. Several chaps tarting up the headstock with filler and wet and dry was the most glaring example. The film clearly showed the attention to detail that made Colchester successful. At the same period Dean Smith & Grace were famously the Rolls Royce of lathe makers; I wonder if they made a similar film showing what has to be done to make a better lathe than a Colchester? Whatever it is, it's expensive! Although manual lathes still have an important role, they haven't been mainstream in manufacturing production for at least 50 years. Even capstan lathes were 'old-hat' when the film made, and - although they too still have a role - they were progressively elbowed aside by various automatics. First Cam & hydraulic, then Numeric Control, then CNC, and now CAD/CAM and Robots. Not much demand for 1955-style capstan lathes today! There's a feeling on the forum that British Industry has gone to the dogs. It's true manufacturing is no longer the main way Great Britain makes a living. It's also true that manufacturing is much less obvious, the chimneys, slag heaps, marshalling yards, furnaces, factories and mills have mostly gone. So has making cheap items like tin trays, steel buckets, penknives, and mops. Millions of jobs have gone too. But last time I checked, British Industry was making slightly more profit than it did in the glorious 1950's. Rather than packing giant factories with people, industry now operates from small anonymous units in business parks. Machine centres are the most popular machine tools like this example. Manufacturing has mostly moved up market; aerospace rather than nails, and pharmaceuticals rather than fertiliser. It's a bad mistake to confuse busy activity with success. As I write it looks as if British Steel has reached the end of the road. The big problem isn't politics, Health and Safety, mismanagement or Brussels, it's that Coal and Iron Ore both have to be imported because the local natural resources are exhausted. All good things come to an end, the important thing is to move on. Dave
|
Alan Jackson | 31/05/2019 11:07:01 |
![]() 276 forum posts 149 photos | I visited the factory as an apprentice in about 1957, so this video reminds me of that visit. I think the whole factory was very proud of the machines they produced. Here is a photo of my Chipmaster, still going well. I have rebuilt this old lathe and I think it now runs nearly as good as it ever did. Replaced the speed variator with an inverter, modified the cross slide and added a new lever locking top slide, plus the capstan feed tailstock Alan |
larry phelan 1 | 31/05/2019 11:30:46 |
1346 forum posts 15 photos | Beautiful machines ,alas I will never get to own one. |
mechman48 | 31/05/2019 11:34:03 |
![]() 2947 forum posts 468 photos | Alan; lovely machine, have you just cleaned it or haven't you used it yet, pristine condition... George. |
Russell Eberhardt | 31/05/2019 11:37:23 |
![]() 2785 forum posts 87 photos | Interesting to compare with modern Chinese factories like this. The most noticeable difference is the cleanliness of the modern factory. I wonder if Ketan can find a video of the Seig factory. Russell |
Stuart Bridger | 31/05/2019 11:40:24 |
566 forum posts 31 photos | Alas my Chipmaster is not as shiny as Alan's. It is still much better than my capabilities though. 1963 model bought from a local engineering shop. Originally supplied to the REME training workshop at Aborfield. Imperial model fitted with dual dials, which I understand is quite rare. Original splash guard went AWOL, so the guys I bought it from fabricated a new one for me FOC. Converted to single phase with a VFD, although retaining the variator. Recent addition is a taper turning attachment. Edited By Stuart Bridger on 31/05/2019 11:42:31 |
Former Member | 31/05/2019 11:49:45 |
[This posting has been removed] | |
Brian Oldford | 31/05/2019 12:06:07 |
![]() 686 forum posts 18 photos | Posted by DC31k on 31/05/2019 07:06:11:
Would it have been kerosene? He says 'spirit carrier', so much more likely alcohol-based. Paraffin ignited in that manner would be rather smoky. What interests me is all the gold-coloured machines they use to make the lathes. Did they paint them up specially for the film or was every machine in the factory that colour? The material in the spirit carrier would have been what's known in some foundries as plumbago. It leaves a coating of graphite on the mould cavity which helps bind the surface of the sand mould and impart an improved finish to the casting. It acts as a binder to the sand and significantly reduces any erosion to the sand as the iron is flowing into the mould cavity. |
mgnbuk | 31/05/2019 14:11:41 |
1394 forum posts 103 photos | That doesn't look a whole lot different than Boxfords at Boxtrees Mill in the early '80s, though Boxford didn't have their own foundy & all the castings were "weathered" outside for months before clean-up in a similar shot blaster. The filler used then was two part polyester body filler, still rubbed down by hand. Today's Student and M300 are badge engineered clones of each other. And currently built in Taiwan. They have also variously been built in recent years in Russia, Czech Republic & China. The TS Harrison plant in Heckmondwike, which is where Colchester Lathes production was re-located after the site shown was sold (IIRC to become a Tesco supermarket) was closed last year. The last products made there were the Harrison Alpha "manual plus" lathes & Colchester Tornado slant bed CNCs - it is probably at least 15 years since the last manual lathe was made there. My brother in law served his time at TS Harrison & was charge hand on the small turned parts & gear cutting section - he left when production of the manual machines ceased, as the variety of parts for the CNC machines was very small. Even then the M250 was made in Russia & I recall around the same time the owner of a machine shop I used in my last employment being very unhappy to find that the "top of the range" Colchester he bought new was actually a re-badged Czech machine. The graphite product used to face the sand mould was probably DAG colloidal graphite suspension, which is supended in alchohol. It is still available & we have a 205 litre drum at work for use in vacuum furnace applications. The paint used to seal gearbox internals was also spirit based. When I worked at Broadbent Machine Tools as an electrician wiring heavy duty lathes, we used to use it to paint out the insides of the electrical sections of castings (the fitters did the gearbox castings & didn't touch "electrical" bits !). It was quite a "claggy" paint that dried very fast - clean-up & thinning was done with methylated spirit. When dried oil didn't soften it & one of it's purposes was to bind any sand remaining in the casting to prevent it getting in to the oil and causing wear. Nigel B |
ronan walsh | 31/05/2019 15:03:11 |
546 forum posts 32 photos | Colchesters ? Piles of absolute rubbish, toytown lathes. Having worked in many workshops professionally as a turner, i never had any time for them. Harrisons are better machines, if you wanted something from the 600 group. The headstocks get noisey after the first bit of hard work, the supposedly hardened bedways are rapid wear, they leak oil, get loose generally, the finish is appalling, and the price of spares is daylight robbery. The only decent colchester i ever seen was a Japanese copy, it was vastly superior to the english made machines. Someone said they were disappointed to discover the modern colchesters are made in czech republic or somewhere around there ? Why ? Tos are czech and are top notch machines, light years ahead of colchesters. I seen 50 year old tos lathes that were better than 5 year old (or less) colchesters. If you think i am wrong, head over to the practical machinist forum and ask for opinions on them, but be warned, put on your tin helmet and be ready to take cover.
|
Samsaranda | 31/05/2019 16:17:40 |
![]() 1688 forum posts 16 photos | Dave, you mention that coal and iron ore have to be imported because local resources have been exhausted, I was under the impression that in respect of coal there were at least 100 years of resources left in the ground when the politicians decided to close our mines, the other factor was a commercial one the price of imported coal undercut our home product. Dave W |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.