This review of different digital calipers was first published in MEW 248.
Tony Marshall | 12/02/2017 17:26:54 |
![]() 16 forum posts 38 photos | Posted by Michael Gilligan on 12/02/2017 14:31:21:
Posted by Tony Marshall on 12/02/2017 13:57:11:
... (not my spelling!) ... . 'though it is the traditional 'British English' spelling of the item also known as Calipers. MichaelG. [only mentioned to balance your exclamation mark] I stand corrected. My reference books must have American contributors. Note to self, don't make assumptions. Many thanks. |
JA | 12/02/2017 17:35:33 |
![]() 1605 forum posts 83 photos | I bought my first digital calipers 15 - 20 years ago from a well known tool shop. It was cheap, Chinese and became useless after about two years. Thinking I could do better I visited my local engineering merchants to see what they had. I came away with a Swiss made TESA IP65 digital calipers which cost about 8x the earlier calipers. I still use it and it has given me excellent service. TESA calipers are still available but I haven't a clue where I would get one from. I don't think you will find them on eBay and the local engineering merchants is long since gone. JA
Edited By JA on 12/02/2017 17:42:08 |
Engine Builder | 12/02/2017 17:36:23 |
![]() 267 forum posts | Mitutoyo for me. I recently was able to buy a replacement battery cover for mine. How many other makes will offer spare parts? I actually had to buy 4 to make up the minimum order , I have an ad in the for sale section if anyone needs one, I have 3 spares. |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 17:51:32 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos | So, are these the real thing mYAAOSwjDZYlwuv
Having now seen the cost I can only assume fake Edited By petro1head on 12/02/2017 18:04:04 |
ronan walsh | 12/02/2017 18:07:16 |
546 forum posts 32 photos | You cannot beat mitutoyo. I have a pair for 20 years nearly and they have been perfect. Beware though there are counterfeits/ fakes being peddled. On ebay you know they are fake because they have country of origin as hong kong. |
Michael Gilligan | 12/02/2017 18:09:47 |
![]() 23121 forum posts 1360 photos | Posted by petro1head on 12/02/2017 17:51:32:
So, are these the real thing mYAAOSwjDZYlwuv . Couldn't be certain ... but: **LINK** http://orcinus24x5.tumblr.com/post/85895171143/fake-mitutoyo-digital-caliper-from-ebay-real-one MichaelG. |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 18:16:26 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos |
Posted by ronan walsh on 12/02/2017 18:07:16: You cannot beat mitutoyo. I have a pair for 20 years nearly and they have been perfect. Beware though there are counterfeits/ fakes being peddled. On ebay you know they are fake because they have country of origin as hong kong. Unless bought from Hong Kong and then resold in uk Ok. So there seems a huge gap between cheap Ones and more expensive i.e.£10 to £135 There must be something in the middle cost wise and less chance of fake. What obout Moore and Wright |
Neil Wyatt | 12/02/2017 18:22:25 |
![]() 19226 forum posts 749 photos 86 articles | M&W do verniers at various price points. The top of the range are equivalent to Mitutoyo, but the mid-price ones are very good. In my test I also found the 'cheap as chips' ones from Machine DRO are nicer than supermarket ones - ideal for workshop hack. On a budget, grab a cheap hack pair and a mid-price M&W for best. But I've been spoiled and now use the Mitutoyo* for everything (I really ought to use a cheaper pair for most stuff...) Neil * I actually had to reset the origin today, hadn't used it for a few weeks and it was slightly out. I think that's the second or third time in several months, which isn't bad. |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 18:29:35 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos | Posted by Neil Wyatt on 12/02/2017 18:22:25:
M&W do verniers at various price points. The top of the range are equivalent to Mitutoyo, but the mid-price ones are very good. In my test I also found the 'cheap as chips' ones from Machine DRO are nicer than supermarket ones - ideal for workshop hack. On a budget, grab a cheap hack pair and a mid-price M&W for best. But I've been spoiled and now use the Mitutoyo* for everything (I really ought to use a cheaper pair for most stuff...) Neil * I actually had to reset the origin today, hadn't used it for a few weeks and it was slightly out. I think that's the second or third time in several months, which isn't bad. What would you say is a mid price point |
ronan walsh | 12/02/2017 18:35:46 |
546 forum posts 32 photos | Posted by petro1head on 12/02/2017 18:16:26:
Posted by ronan walsh on 12/02/2017 18:07:16: You cannot beat mitutoyo. I have a pair for 20 years nearly and they have been perfect. Beware though there are counterfeits/ fakes being peddled. On ebay you know they are fake because they have country of origin as hong kong. Unless bought from Hong Kong and then resold in uk Ok. So there seems a huge gap between cheap Ones and more expensive i.e.£10 to £135 There must be something in the middle cost wise and less chance of fake. What obout Moore and Wright Which is why you buy from a reputable source like cromwell or other known stockists, not some chancer on ebay operating out of a garden shed, or cupboard under the stairs. Kennedy is another reasonable brand, they do a set with larger than normal numbers, good if your minces aren't too good anymore. |
sean logie | 12/02/2017 18:36:24 |
![]() 608 forum posts 7 photos | If my memory serves me right (which i doubt) the picture on the box on the ebay link is wrong ,the calipers should be pointing up to the top left corner instead of bottom left .
Sean |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 18:53:43 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos | Posted by ronan walsh on 12/02/2017 18:35:46:
Posted by petro1head on 12/02/2017 18:16:26:
Posted by ronan walsh on 12/02/2017 18:07:16: You cannot beat mitutoyo. I have a pair for 20 years nearly and they have been perfect. Beware though there are counterfeits/ fakes being peddled. On ebay you know they are fake because they have country of origin as hong kong. Unless bought from Hong Kong and then resold in uk Ok. So there seems a huge gap between cheap Ones and more expensive i.e.£10 to £135 There must be something in the middle cost wise and less chance of fake. What obout Moore and Wright good if your minces aren't too good anymore. Hmm that will be me then |
Muzzer | 12/02/2017 18:55:27 |
![]() 2904 forum posts 448 photos | Aldi currently selling some for £8.50. No experience of them myself but they could double as adjustable spanner / hammer at that price. |
Neil Wyatt | 12/02/2017 19:02:53 |
![]() 19226 forum posts 749 photos 86 articles | Posted by petro1head on 12/02/2017 18:29:35:
What would you say is a mid price point How about £23.70 on special offer? www.machine-dro.co.uk/150mm-6-digitronic-digital-caliper-moore-wright-basic-line-110-dbl-series.html M&W for the price of three Aldi pairs? Hardly makes sense to buy anything else? Neil |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 19:06:48 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos |
Out of curiosity I have been having a look at what caliper I have. I could do with something of a known measurement to test accuracy. 1. Clarke - not too bad but not a smooth action 2. Work zone - not sure about accuracy but smooth 3. Unbranded - got these as a birthday gift, crap crap crap 4. I have also found some Mitutoyo non did Gita like fine adjustment, very smooth action |
MalcB | 12/02/2017 19:16:54 |
257 forum posts 35 photos | Posted by Neil Wyatt on 12/02/2017 18:22:25:
M&W do verniers at various price points. The top of the range are equivalent to Mitutoyo, but the mid-price ones are very good. In my test I also found the 'cheap as chips' ones from Machine DRO are nicer than supermarket ones - ideal for workshop hack. On a budget, grab a cheap hack pair and a mid-price M&W for best. But I've been spoiled and now use the Mitutoyo* for everything (I really ought to use a cheaper pair for most stuff...) Neil * I actually had to reset the origin today, hadn't used it for a few weeks and it was slightly out. I think that's the second or third time in several months, which isn't bad.
I have bought the M & W one from DRO that Neil tested in MEW, based on being above the budget level and suitable for everyday use. I bought it to ease up on the use of my Tesa 6"/150mm digital vernier which i have had for about 20 yrs now. Using the M & W more and more now and finding nice to handle for daily use. For information We bought a bundle of 20 x Tesa at work along side quite a few Mitutoyo digitals ( about 8ish). Again about 20 yrs ago. Throughout their useful life the Tesa actually showed consistantly better calibration results from an external cal laboratory. Not a lot in it but they were better. Dont know how the newer models would stack up today side by side. There are a few Starrett digitals and dial ones now starting to appear which are allegedly still being made in the USA and which appear to be well priced against the Mitutoyo. I would be really interest to see how these perform as my Tesa will need replacing.
|
Toby | 12/02/2017 19:17:21 |
117 forum posts 17 photos | Keep an eye on MSC, they occasionally have mytutoyo verniers on sale. eg this one: **LINK** was selling for £59.99 (plus vat) a couple of weeks ago. Personally I have a couple of cheap Moore and Wright 6" from machine DRO, these ones: I was testing one of them today against some slip gauges and they were no more than 1/2 a thou out (which is their resolution) from 1/4" to 3". Given the slip gauges are probably well over 50 years old and more than a bit rusty in places I didn't think that was too bad More importantly they are consistent, even with a significant variation in pressure, something I have found a problem with the cheap no-name verniers I have. |
fizzy | 12/02/2017 19:21:43 |
![]() 1860 forum posts 121 photos | My mid range set are Sealey - I use the cheapo ones as well. Given the variability in results (once did a very boring gauge R&R on it) there seems no benefit accuracy wise in buying expensive. |
Nick_G | 12/02/2017 19:28:52 |
![]() 1808 forum posts 744 photos | Posted by Neil Wyatt on 12/02/2017 19:02:53:
Posted by petro1head on 12/02/2017 18:29:35:
What would you say is a mid price point How about £23.70 on special offer? www.machine-dro.co.uk/150mm-6-digitronic-digital-caliper-moore-wright-basic-line-110-dbl-series.html
Neil . Those are the M&W ones I mentioned previously that ended up in my junk bin. Nick |
petro1head | 12/02/2017 19:31:29 |
![]() 984 forum posts 207 photos | What are absolute digital calipers |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.