Forum sponsored by:

Comments on the Exhibition

Some thoughts three weeks on

Search for: in Thread Title in

Peter Cobban 1	31/12/2009 19:58:53
4 forum posts 2 photos	I hope that this is the right place to comment on the Exhibition. Point one: Well done to you all, you have resurrected the Exhibition from the dead. The trade stands were good, the demonstrations excellent and the one lecture that I attended was very informative to a beginner. The poor points were the models entered and loaned. Where were they? From the "engineering" point of view, there were some nice exhibits, but the Boats? Perhaps, you could go back to entries from the whole spectrum of modelling, figures, cars, small locomotives (oo guage), and planes. Surely there must be people mking models of a highest enough standard. Perhaps, you could talk to the IPMS, and allow them to run their own competition to their rules. (enough of rules they have caused controversy already) Lets turn the whole thing open to all, and see a modern version of the Exhibitions of yeteryear. Excellent work, keep going.
Peter Gain	31/12/2009 20:53:56
103 forum posts	Yes, an excellent exhibition. BUT. Please remember that the exhibition is for "Model Engineering". Please, no more bits plastic & cardboard models. Whilst such models may be worthy of critical acclaim, they are NOT "Model Engineering". We had a plethora of plastic models a few years ago, they have their place, but not in an engineering exhibition. Exhibits should be substantially of metal which has been turned, milled, filed, & etc. No more "Blue Peter" models, please. Peter Gain.
David Clark 1	31/12/2009 21:36:15
3357 forum posts 112 photos 10 articles	Hi There Yes, good quality machined or hand made models from wood and metal etc. I believe there was a superb locomotive entered a few years ago, perfect in every way then one of the judges opened the firebox door. Made out of cardboard it was. regards David
Peter Gain	01/01/2010 10:35:51
103 forum posts	Hi, I remember the cardboard loco, an excellent example of the model maker's art. BUT. Not model engineering! Regards, Peter.
John Haine	01/01/2010 10:58:13
5563 forum posts 322 photos	On the contrary, surely? My father-in-law taught packaging design and was a master of "paper engineering"....making effective complex structures from cardboard is a very specialised technique fully deserving of being described as engineering.
Peter Cobban 1	01/01/2010 14:15:58
4 forum posts 2 photos	Yes, I agree with all the comments above, but we need to promote our hobby in all forms. When Model Enginer was first published, aircraft were a rarity, cars were for the few, and pleasure boating was in its infancy. We now have new materials, and best of all, new ideas. Plastic is here to stay. Let's embrace all the disciplines and learn from them. BUT ABOVE ALL HAVE FUN MODELLING Cheers Peter
Chris Trice	18/12/2010 17:31:37
1376 forum posts 10 photos	Genetic engineering is technically 'engineering' so it's not good to get caught up too much in a pedantic discussion about the definition. In broad terms, most people understand what 'Model Engineering' means and it doesn't usually bring cardboard models or plastic kits into mind. Why not origami models? I have no objection to either but the show would become a model show and not a model engineering show. How do you define what qualifies? Hard to quantify but you know it when you see it. Anyone remember a well known pen manufacturer promoting a competition to make models out of old ball point pen bodies? One was a traction engine. Would that count? Amusing and clever, yes, but not what the show is about. I think there is room to broaden the scope a little particularly when you get into radio control model territory which encompasses some model engineering practice but the wider you brush, the thinner the coat of paint. Edited By Chris Trice on 18/12/2010 17:36:38
Chris Trice	18/12/2010 17:35:45
1376 forum posts 10 photos	BTW, I go to the IPMS show at Telford each year and don't see anyone saying that more model engineering type models should appear when the P in IPMS stands for 'plastic'. Model Engineering is principly (but not exclusively) about machining metal.
Stub Mandrel	18/12/2010 17:59:32
4318 forum posts 291 photos 1 articles	I once entered a model in MMEX, largely because it was easy for me to get to. With a SIL who works for an international parcel I'm loathe to commit any of my models to a system that expects staff to scan,sort and load 300 parcels an hour onto a lorry! So how could I enter a model for a show in London, when getting there for one day is hard enough, and attending the first (or even earlier) and last would be too much. I understand that at one time a foremer editor (Ted Joliffe?) and a companion would make a lazy winding tour down the length of the UK, making various rendevous at services etc. collecting boxed models. The exercise was repeated in reverse after the exhibition. I can see 101 possible pitfalls (e.g heavy snow or what happens if a modeller doesn't arrive to collect the model on time), but is there some way of collecting and distributing a wider range of models. Or you could move the MEX to the Midlands where it should be Neil
Billy Mills	18/12/2010 18:08:33
377 forum posts	Enjoyed the exhibition but two weeks from Christmas is a bit late in the year. For me the best reason for the trip was the SMEE stand where you can always learn something new. If you had not been to the show before it was easy to miss the models upstairs, perhaps I failed to see the signs? Regards, Alan.
KWIL	18/12/2010 18:58:42
3681 forum posts 70 photos	Not just missing the signs?? There were numerous loudspeaker announcements about the Club Stands and the Competition entries being on the first floor. Apart from that, did nobody think to ask anyone? The SMEE members would have known as would most of the Traders, they made it upstairs during their breaks. How do I know? I was a Steward up there.
David Clark 1	18/12/2010 21:45:46
3357 forum posts 112 photos 10 articles	Hi There I did quite a few announcments about the club stands and competition entries upstairs and the ground level 5in. gauge being outside. regards david
Chris Trice	18/12/2010 22:40:52
1376 forum posts 10 photos	I confess I only looked upstairs because I knew from previous years there were exhibits up there. Personally, I rarely pay any attention to tannoy announcements if I'm in the middle of a purchase with a trader. The first thing I looked for was signage by the stairs even if it was just an A4 printed arrow stuck to the wall saying more exhibits upstairs. Didn't see any but had a nosey anyway. Hope that constitutes constructive feedback.
Nicholas Farr	18/12/2010 22:42:10
3988 forum posts 1799 photos	Hi, I had no trouble knowing that there were models upstairs, even the first year it was held at Sandown. As far as content is concerned, I regard "Model Engineering" to be fundementally using metal and the use of metal turning lathes and such assoceated machines, but not totally excluding other materials. But I think it should have some relevance. As far as the venue and time of year is concerned, I don't think it will ever suit everybody. When I first started to go to the annual exhibition it was in Olympia (which I've favoured most) and was in the first week of January, which for me was ideal, as it was both an easy trip on the train and underground and fitted well into my work schedule. It was held at Olympia for many years, and at least once at Alexadrea Palace. Since its been at Sandown, apart from the two years at Ascot, its now a 300 mile round trip for me. A train journey not being practical time wise, but luckely since the change in venues and a different time of year, my work schedule has not been an issue to be concerned about. I think if you have an interest in the show you will be able to tolerate when and where it is held, however I appreciate it is not always easy foe everone. I for one don't have anyone else to consider when attending this or any other exhibition, like many other people do. Regards Nick.
dave cotton	18/12/2010 22:42:33
1 forum posts	hi had a great time at sandown great job done by all many thanks. was not impressed with the some off the staff on chester stand,while i was looking at a cabinet i opened the door and it fell of and it hit the floor with a crash they came over and treated me like i had done this on purpose which i had not it was just bad workmanship so now i have chester mill but it will have a stand from someone else. but still a great day out. Edited By dave cotton on 18/12/2010 22:43:55
John Stevenson	19/12/2010 11:37:58
5068 forum posts 3 photos	The problem is that there are two many show in a short space of time. At one time there was the 'official' ME show which has been at Olympia, Wembley and Ally Pally and held in the beginning of January. Since private venture shows have been organised and have gotten regular slots it's squashed the year up. Holding the ME show at the same time as it was would now clash with the TEE organised Ally Pally show around the 19 / 20th of January. Traders won't do two shows that close as the takings are diluted but expenses are still the same. Whether you agree with traders or not they are needed, gate fees will not cover a show when club stands have to be given free plus loads of free tickets for club stewards. It's the lack of traders what worry me, they are losing them all the while to rising costs and not being replaced by new. This then causes a knock on effect in that organisers increase prices to make up the shortfall and this forces more out. It has happened as the Pickering show has proved and has been forced to close. IMHO December is not the time to hold a show, it's a short month given the Christmas and new years holidays and a busy time with the lead up to Christmas but many traders are also internet based as regards sales so they have to close at what could be a busy time and move to an expensive show where they are not guaranteed making a profit over expenditure given transport, hotel, meals and stand costs. So for many given Christmas and a December show they could be down to a 10 - 14 day working month. Running two London shows within a month is stupid. Take a look at the most successful show we have on the calendar at the moment which is Harrogate in May. Around 24,000 people thru the doors in 3 days, none other come close. The main reason is it's far enough away from other shows in time and location to make it a must go - just like the original ME show. It's the only show I have seen where literally 1,000's of pounds in Scottish money changes hands. People go there to spend, they go to other shows to look and it might sound very vulgar and commercial but these shows ARE commercial and have to be to exist. Instead of diluting shows within the M25 area which won't help anyone in the long run take a better look at the map of the UK. Did you know there is no show of any decent size in the North West and no I don't live there so no vested interest. Do a show around September around Preston / Blackpool and you will get all the Scots back down again as whey will had had a 6 month break from Harrogate. John S. Edited By John Stevenson on 19/12/2010 11:38:46
magpie	19/12/2010 15:15:19
508 forum posts 98 photos	I agree with everything said by John S above.I know lots of folk who go to harrogate every year, but will not go anywhere near the south east as public transport is too expensive and time consuming, and the roads are chaotic Merry Christmass everyone Cheers Derek
AndyB	19/12/2010 19:13:59
167 forum posts 7 photos	SWIMBO and I both thought that the show was excellent. She did putter for a while, until we had explored all the little rooms, then she found not one but two ploughing engines, so that made her day! (She is so easy to please!) I was completely stunned and in total awe of the model Bentley engine, especially when fired up. It sounded exactly like the original! We actually like the layout with the different bits all over the place; it gives the opportunity to look closely without competing with others for the view. Larger rooms tend to have larger groups of people around the exhibits. One thing to say about the boats; the chap with the lifeboat had the top off when we got to see it. No lack of engineering there! He had made non-running scale models of the engines which unclipped to be replaced by electric motors for sailing. The hull was jammed full of controls and gizmos that surely warrant the 'engineering' epithet. To my way of thinking, there is a broad enough spectrum to interest the wider paying public. If there was not then only a narrow section of attendance would insufficiently fill the coffers that generate this type of exhibition. No gate money, no show. Limited market, no trade stands. As to location; we come from wildest East Anglia. Nothing big happens within 3 or 4 hours travelling because of limited population. We have to travel to where the townies live because the number of them in one spot means that stuff happens. Our choice and we are happy with it.
Terryd	20/12/2010 11:38:30
1946 forum posts 179 photos	Posted by Peter Gain on 31/12/2009 20:53:56: Yes, an excellent exhibition. BUT. Please remember that the exhibition is for "Model Engineering". Please, no more bits plastic & cardboard models. Whilst such models may be worthy of critical acclaim, they are NOT "Model Engineering". We had a plethora of plastic models a few years ago, they have their place, but not in an engineering exhibition. Exhibits should be substantially of metal which has been turned, milled, filed, & etc. No more "Blue Peter" models, please. Peter Gain. Hi Peter, So if I made a model of say, Harrison's wooden clock, I would have to make it out of metal in order to qualify? Or if I made a fully machined and hand filed clock out of Perspex (with a few metal bits) that would not be acceptable being plastic? I also see that there is quite a lot of engineering using modern materials and CNC methods (no manual machining or filing there) being used on the stand of the Society of Model and Experimental Engineers, should they be barred? While on the subject of clocks, as you rightly point out it is a Model Engineering exhibition yet I see many full size working clocks which are definitely not models, so if we have to adopt narrow interpretations and didactic definitions of the title we should not have those? Just asking for clarification of your ideas. Best regards Terry
KWIL	20/12/2010 11:56:46
3681 forum posts 70 photos	Models are built to scale, nobody has said that the scale cannot be 12" = 1ft.

1 2 3 4 Next > Last >>

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts

hemingway ball turner
04/07/2025 14:40:26
*Oct 2023: FORUM MIGRATION TIMELINE*
05/10/2023 07:57:11
Making ER11 collet chuck
05/10/2023 07:56:24
What did you do today? 2023
05/10/2023 07:25:01
Orrery
05/10/2023 06:00:41
Wera hand-tools
05/10/2023 05:47:07
New member
05/10/2023 04:40:11
Problems with external pot on at1 vfd
05/10/2023 00:06:32
Drain plug
04/10/2023 23:36:17
digi phase converter for 10 machines.....
04/10/2023 23:13:48
More Latest Posts...
View All Topics

Support Our Partners

Shopping Partners

Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads

Reeves** - Rebuilt Royal Scot by Martin Evans
by John Broughton
£300.00
BRITANNIA 5" GAUGE James Perrier
by Jon Seabright 1
£2,500.00
Drill Grinder - for restoration
by Nigel Graham 2
£0.00
WARCO WM18 MILLING MACHINE
by Alex Chudley
£1,200.00
MYFORD SUPER 7 LATHE
by Alex Chudley
£2,000.00
More "For Sale" Ads...

Latest "Wanted" Ads

D1-3 backplate
by Michael Horley
Price Not Specified
fixed steady for a Colchester bantam mark1 800
by George Jervis
Price Not Specified
lbsc pansy
by JACK SIDEBOTHAM
Price Not Specified
Pratt Burnerd multifit chuck key.
by Tim Riome
Price Not Specified
BANDSAW BLADE WELDER
by HUGH
Price Not Specified
More "Wanted" Ads...

Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues