Should I have the existng motor rebuilt or replace it
Mark Simpson 1 | 16/01/2015 10:04:09 |
115 forum posts 30 photos | I bought a part rebuilt Union Tool cutter /Grinder from a well known auction site. With the need to be able to sharpen Endmills, Slotdrills MT drills, and hoping to be able to do a little surface grinding; there was a 10" x 5" mag chuck with it Built a new universal head, that takes R8 collets, and managed to make usable a tupperware of 1/4" - 3/4" cutters; finish was not so great on the bigger cutters so investigated the motor (3 Phase squirrel cage)... All I had previously done was to shim it horizontal to the work table. The bearings are single row ball races, on a bent shaft that used to be 5/8, but now .005 - .007 less than that and sort of ellipical. There were no seals on the shaft other than the endcaps (now also oversize and oval). End float was removed using two wavy shim washer...All of this was full of congealed oil and grinding dust; very effective grinding paste - It's stuffed. I've seen the wonders than John Stevenson can perform, but it will cost me as much for the bearings, seals, and a heap of time to have a working 40 year old motor. Any good reason why I don't buy an off the shelf foot mounted motor, with dust seals and make a new mounting plate? It would also mean that the ability to rotate the motor wouldn't need bent spanners, a torch and skinned knuckles (the bolts are inside the motor mount!).The Worden uses such a motor. Single Phase would also save the use of my inverter for the lathe and mill,it's only need 375Watts and the original was single speed. I am sure this forum will now tell me what I'm failing to see
p.s. I know I would not be restoring it to it's former glory, but it might standa chance of being more useful!
|
Dusty | 16/01/2015 12:11:26 |
498 forum posts 9 photos | Mark, you purchased the machine to use, not as a restoration job. I would buy a new motor, you can have it up and running again in a few days. I do not know much about lectrickery other than if you grab the end of the red wire it hurts. I am given to understand that 3phase will give smoother running than single, which in the case of a grinder is usefull. I am sure that there are many on here that are better qualified than me to advise on the relative merits of the two types of motor.I would suspect that the cost of refurbishment is equal if not greater than buying new. |
Les Jones 1 | 16/01/2015 12:50:57 |
2292 forum posts 159 photos | Hi Mark, Les. |
Mark Simpson 1 | 16/01/2015 16:53:13 |
115 forum posts 30 photos | Thanks Les and Dusty.
One ended will be fine,but had anticipated stripping motor and threading the end as I have a stack of 1/2" UNF wheel adaptors already made. A bench grinder is a great suggestions Les, and the centre height would be about right as well I'll keep the old motor anyway, incase I sell it on! Cheers! |
Les Jones 1 | 16/01/2015 19:52:19 |
2292 forum posts 159 photos | Hi Mark, Les. |
Ray Lyons | 16/01/2015 21:17:23 |
200 forum posts 1 photos | Hi Mark, I have a similar grinder but mine is fitted with a single phase motor with a very old type rotary switch mounted on top of the motor. I have seen photos of one which has been converted using a bench grinder. Don't know about the electrics but the shafts on mine have one end right hand threaded and the other left handed. Have to be careful to switch the motor in the right direction on start up.
|
Les Jones 1 | 16/01/2015 22:46:02 |
2292 forum posts 159 photos | Hi Ray, Les. |
John Stevenson | 16/01/2015 23:32:17 |
![]() 5068 forum posts 3 photos | Mark, What neck of the woods are you from ? |
Ray Lyons | 17/01/2015 06:54:50 |
200 forum posts 1 photos | Hi Les, On my grinder, the motor can be turned through 180d so that the drive shafts are reversed. I usually use the right hand threaded end for surface grinding to avoid having to set the cutters up to grind on the left side of the machine. With the rotary switch, it is an easy mistake to turn the motor in the wrong direction which fortunately for me,on the very rare occasion has resulted in a loose wheel and not the disaster which could result. Ray |
Phil P | 17/01/2015 12:52:00 |
851 forum posts 206 photos | I had similar issues when I rebuilt my Union grinder, another problem is the motor speed is not high enough for the smaller cup wheels. I decided to do my own thing and make a complete new variable speed head for mine. The head also fits straight on to the Myford cross slide for odd cylindrical grinding jobs. I also rigged up a head for doing four facet drill grinding, see photo's in album.
Phil |
Ian S C | 18/01/2015 05:14:25 |
![]() 7468 forum posts 230 photos | Phil, that looks quite a set up you have. It's OK to increase the speed of a stone as long as it remains within the allowable maximum revs, nobody wants to see what happens when a stone bursts, if in doubt, err on the slow side.(not aimed at you Phil, but newbies). Ian S C |
Mark Simpson 1 | 18/01/2015 17:13:12 |
115 forum posts 30 photos | Thanks Everyone, (been away from computer for a couple of days). This forum really helps one think through things (without making as much scrap!) John: I'm between Macclesfield and Buxton. Les and Ray: I'm aware of the LH / RH thread issue,a reasonable quality Bench Grinder would solve that, not thought properly about the Keyway (thanks Les) but I imagined making a keyed adaptor to the 1/2" shafts of my exisitng stuff.... Cheers, Mark
|
Phil P | 18/01/2015 19:29:01 |
851 forum posts 206 photos | This is what it looks like on the Myford doing a spot of crank journal grinding for a model petrol engine crank made from solid bar.
Phil |
Eric Storey | 24/08/2015 22:29:33 |
2 forum posts | I originally started a new thread with the post below but as you guys must know the answer, can anyone assist me please. Has anyone got a parts manual or maintenance manual for a Union Tool and Cutter Grinder? I have the operation manual but this gives little or no information regarding parts and maintenance. I particularly want to know the assembly of the drive for racking the table from left to right as mine seems to have been altered to a direct drive. I believe that the assembly that the handle fits to should have gears in it. If this is so, what is the arrangement, size of gears etc. Eric. |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.