By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

Cam Calculations

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
ChrisH26/01/2017 19:21:39
1023 forum posts
30 photos

Does anyone have a link to a cam calculation programme for calculating the cam profiles for an I.C. engine? Thinking, design your own engine here.

The modelenginenews website used to have a programme, but it does not seem to be working since we turned the New Year.

Chris

Roderick Jenkins26/01/2017 19:50:55
avatar
2376 forum posts
800 photos

Chris,

If you have Excel then my cam spreadsheet can be copied from my Drop box here

Change any of the entries in the blue boxes on the data entry sheet (no.1) to get the cam profile. If the cam drawing goes wonky then the figures entered do not give a solution. PM me if you need further advice.

HTH,

Rod

ChrisH26/01/2017 20:34:42
1023 forum posts
30 photos

Thanks Rod, have sent you a PM.

Chris

Tim Stevens26/01/2017 22:39:40
avatar
1779 forum posts
1 photos

There are really two problems to solve - both of which can be complex.

I think the OP wants to know how to draw, or to make a cam which meets given criteria - probably both draw and then make.

The more important question which bothers the designer is 'What are the correct criteria for this engine?' Not merely the opening and closing angles, but the lift, the accelerations and decelerations that the various bits will stand at peak revs, and so on. Much of this can be left to a million dollar computer and a flock of geeks, but there is always a good chance that when they have done their best, someone with fifty years of dirty fingernails will tweak another few revs, or Watts, out of it all.

In my limited experience, a ploy that works reasonably well is to design what theory tells you will give the dwell and lift (etc) you know the mechanicals will stand, and make test cams with a vernier fitting to the shaft giving options no more than 2 degrees apart.. Then you can play with openings and overlap, etc, knowing that the basic mechanicals are Ok, and you are 'only' altering the pneumatics.

Some of my experience was gained at the bench at BSA while they were not making Tiger Cubs ...

Cheers, Tim

stevetee27/01/2017 00:41:47
145 forum posts
14 photos

Following on from Tims comments, if I may , the shape of the cam follower is also vitally important , flat or radiused and the radius of the follower all affect the rate of opening( and closing), but not the overall lift. If I can remember a flat cam follower will give an aggressive rate of opening wheras a radiused follower is more gentle.

Phil P27/01/2017 07:12:19
851 forum posts
206 photos

I used this method to produce my cams,

http://www.modelenginenews.org/techniques/meek_cams.html

Phil

Roderick Jenkins27/01/2017 11:08:36
avatar
2376 forum posts
800 photos
Posted by stevetee on 27/01/2017 00:41:47:

Following on from Tims comments, if I may , the shape of the cam follower is also vitally important , flat or radiused and the radius of the follower all affect the rate of opening( and closing), but not the overall lift. If I can remember a flat cam follower will give an aggressive rate of opening wheras a radiused follower is more gentle.

These "Harmonic cam" programs let you fiddle around with the design of the cam to get valve opening to be as gentle or as aggressive as you wish. The cam is made of 3 components, the base radius, flank radius and nose radius and a gentle transition from one to the other is ensured by making the transition point share the same radius i.e. the tangents are the same. All this, of course, with a flat follower. The problem that then arises is trying to fit the cam design into the space available in the engine and, particularly, having a round follower that is of sufficient diameter such that the edge of the follower does not ride on the cam (even though some commercial engines including, as I understand it the 1600cc engine in the Maestro, suffered from this "problem" without apparent ill effect). I guess that having a curved follower can help to alleviate this problem. Having some knowledge of the acceleration profile spat out by the cam calc program can help to put the size of spring required to keep follower in contact with the cam in the right ball park. There are, of course, loads of other issues to contend with such as tappet clearances but the programs do give you a good starting point if you are designing the engine from scratch. If you are just trying to make an engine just goes then these considerations are unnecessary but beyond that some calculation can provide a little help.

Cheers,

Rod

CorRad26/09/2017 11:52:34
19 forum posts

A cam Calc spreadsheet is precise what I need right now. Unfortunately, the spreadsheet on Dropbox is not available anymore. Would it please be possible to drop it again.

Thank you

Cor

Roderick Jenkins26/09/2017 12:36:39
avatar
2376 forum posts
800 photos

Sorry, had to clear out my dropbox - too full.

Here's a new link **LINK**

PM if you have any problems.

Rod

Wayne Ward26/09/2017 21:28:41
12 forum posts

Cam design is a really complex job if you are going to look into all aspects of the problem. I can recommend the book by Rothbart "Cams: Design, Dynamics and Accuracy" if you like maths. It's available second-hand and the price has fallen in recent years, presumably because a lot of old boys are retiring and the young pups just rely on incredibly expensive programs to do the calculation for them.

It depends what you are doing. A new engine where you can leave yourself lots of space, where performance is not an issue and where speeds are modest is easier than designing a cam for a racing engine which runs at high speed and where maintaining valve to piston clearances and control of the valve and spring are significant problems.

I wrote a huge spreadsheet in excel many years ago for flat-faced followers where you played with the shape of the acceleration profile until you got an acceptable maximum opening angular velocity (which dictates the size of the follower you need), sufficient oil film thickness between cam and follower, sufficiently low contact stresses between cam and follower (always at the nose at the lowest engine speed), sufficient spring force to maintain a safety margin at max lift / max engine speed etc, all whilst having tangency in the acceleration curve. It took many weeks of work, but it played a significant part in landing me a couple of good jobs.

Curved followers, finger followers, pushrods etc all make the problem more difficult.

To top it all off, every bit of the system is elastic: the camshaft twists and bends, the valve compresses and stretches etc. Designing a desired valve lift profile is one thing, but making the valve do what you expect it to do in a high-speed engine is quite another. Thankfully most people are blissfully ignorant that their valves are not following the designed profile until they get on a valvetrain rig where valve position can be measured with a laser at high speed.

None of this is meant to put you off, just to point out some of the things that you might need to consider.

CorRad27/09/2017 01:59:09
19 forum posts

Hi Rod, thank you very much for the spreadsheet. It works perfectly for my purposes. Regards.Cor

DollyDigger24/08/2020 19:16:23
51 forum posts
7 photos

Is there any chance this spreadsheet is still hanging around somewhere?

thank you

JasonB24/08/2020 19:27:06
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

Try this link Rod posted last week

Edited By JasonB on 24/08/2020 19:31:25

DollyDigger24/08/2020 19:28:29
51 forum posts
7 photos

hi jason that looks like a motor

cheers

JasonB24/08/2020 19:31:55
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

Should be correct now and take you to Rod's Dropbox

DollyDigger24/08/2020 19:43:28
51 forum posts
7 photos
Posted by JasonB on 24/08/2020 19:31:55:

Should be correct now and take you to Rod's Dropbox

Thats brilliant, many thanks

Josh Lewis23/02/2021 16:11:58
1 forum posts

hi does anyone have a working link to the cam excel file as I can't seem to access it and would like to have a look as it would help with my uni degree thanks !

josh

JasonB23/02/2021 16:45:09
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

The one Rod posted in this thread works OK

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Sign up to our Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
cowells
Sarik
MERIDIENNE EXHIBITIONS LTD
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest

 

Donate

donate