Cornish Jack | 25/01/2015 11:47:04 |
1228 forum posts 172 photos | "I'll probably eBay it. / I will be replacing the system and ebay it. " Given that the likely bidders/buyers will be fellow MEs, I trust that they will be listed on the 'bay as the rubbish quality they seem to be!! Rgds Bill |
Mike Bondarczuk | 25/01/2015 12:46:26 |
91 forum posts 6 photos | I can thoroughly recommend A & R and just very purchased another set of four holders which go with the few I already had. I elected to go for 10mm cutters and found insufficient clearance to enable to get low enough for a centre cut so milled 1mm off the face of the top slide base and now all is perfectly OK. Regards, Mike |
Chris Trice | 25/01/2015 13:37:18 |
![]() 1376 forum posts 10 photos | I've had more than a dozen additional holders from A&R. The quality and service has been first class. Other than not having the big "W" engraved on the back of the holders, they're indistinguishable from original Dickson holders. |
Steamgeek | 25/01/2015 15:52:21 |
45 forum posts 4 photos | The quality from A&R is superb, have been in his workshop and his set up is first rate. I use his tool post and holders, far better than Myford supply, if in doubt try a file on the two and see which has the better hardness |
John C | 25/01/2015 19:38:59 |
273 forum posts 95 photos | I will add my total satisfaction with A&R tooholders; I have several, and will probably buy more.......And the beauty is, they are almost the same price as the 'others'. John
Edited By John Corden on 25/01/2015 19:41:51 |
"Bill Hancox" | 26/01/2015 04:39:30 |
![]() 257 forum posts 77 photos | Posted by Jon Gibbs on 25/01/2015 07:46:15:
Hi Bill, They sell through ebay and their service is excellent. HTH Jon Thank you Jon. I will take a look. Cheers Bill |
WorkshopPete | 26/01/2015 09:49:02 |
87 forum posts | Morning All In answer to Harry's request re the Chronos tool holders I bought a couple 3 or 4 years ago to fit a genuine Myford Dickinson tool post and they did not fit. Having access at the time to a surface grinder I had to take 15 thou of one side of each "V" locator slot to get them to sit correctly and allow them to drop down onto the cam. Other wise they seem ok. I would support all the above buy the genuine article and no problems what are our goals to make models or waste time trying to get new poor quality parts to fit our equipment when for for a few pennies more you can buy the correct part. Buy cheap buy twice. Regards
Peter
|
CotswoldsPhil | 26/01/2015 13:56:06 |
![]() 196 forum posts 112 photos | Can you help me identify which QC toolholder I have acquired? When I bought the Super 7 at the end of last year it came with a basic QCTH set. The tool-post fits the top-slide clamp stud perfectly. I have the original box (see photo below), the 2 tool-holders are engraved with the part number 4494-48, and appear hardened. I bought 3 additional holders at the Midlands Show having been told that they were Myford originals and stamped W on the back. I now know (from this Thread) that these were probably manufactured by Weston Engineering. However, the locking cam does not engage as fully as the matching pair of holders. The one shown at the bottom of the photo is part of the set, the one on the right is one of the new ones. The lack of cam action does not appear to affect the operation or stability of the holder when clamped. I would like to purchase some more holders but do not want to waste money on holders which might not fit. Your input would be much appreciated. Regards Phil |
NJH | 26/01/2015 17:28:12 |
![]() 2314 forum posts 139 photos | Phil I wouldn't stress about it. I have an original Myford toolpost on my S7 and 15 holders. Some of these carry the "M" / "W" mark and some don't. They all work just fine. The only requirement of the cam is that it pulls the holder into close engagement with the toolpost and holds it there. If you buy holders that don't fit then these are faulty and, as they are not fit for purpose, you can get a refund/ exchange. You are right thought to want more holders - the real advantage of the QCTP is that you can have all your tools set and quickly change between them. Regards Norman |
korby | 26/01/2015 20:40:17 |
37 forum posts 2 photos | Some years ago at the Ally Pally MEX I bought a QCTP from a well known supplier. It said MYFORD on the box but a couple of months later when I got round to trying it out found the mounting hole was 3/8 not 7/16 as needed for ML7. Well if its hardened and ground I have a problem. It was ground but not hardened so opened up hole OK. Then found tool holders bottomed on the top of the top slide long before the tool tip got anywhere near centre height. Needless to say I had lost the receipt so it sits on the shelf to remind me of my folly. May be it would fit a MINI lathe. Ho Hum |
Harry Wilkes | 26/01/2015 21:35:36 |
![]() 1613 forum posts 72 photos | Thanks for the info Peter thats the same problem I have ! H Posted by Peter Newby on 26/01/2015 09:49:02: Morning All In answer to Harry's request re the Chronos tool holders I bought a couple 3 or 4 years ago to fit a genuine Myford Dickinson tool post and they did not fit. Having access at the time to a surface grinder I had to take 15 thou of one side of each "V" locator slot to get them to sit correctly and allow them to drop down onto the cam. Other wise they seem ok. I would support all the above buy the genuine article and no problems what are our goals to make models or waste time trying to get new poor quality parts to fit our equipment when for for a few pennies more you can buy the correct part. Buy cheap buy twice. Regards
Peter
|
Gavin H | 26/01/2015 22:13:41 |
6 forum posts | I'm very interested to read peoples' thoughts about the clamping position on these type of toolposts. The reason being that I recently bought one for myself which has this problem of the toolholders being clamped tight before the cam has reached (what I consider to be) enough rotation to give a secure grip. I bought and A&R toolpost a few years ago after reading on this forum about them and I have been 100% happy with it, it hasn't ever given me a single problem. However, I bought another one recently which has the above problem and I have been reluctant to use it. I contacted A&R who said that it was intended to be like that in order to compensate for future wear, but surely this is far too much? Unless the cam rotates at least 90 degrees then the toolholder could be pulled loose under heavy or interrupted cuts, couldn't it? I'm not writing this in any way to 'bash' A&R, as I said, my original toolpost that came from them has been perfect and they have been very quick to answer my questions and have very kindly offered me a full refund if I'm not happy. I still need a toolpost to use though so I wondered what other people thought. |
CotswoldsPhil | 27/01/2015 10:58:41 |
![]() 196 forum posts 112 photos | Thanks Norman, I think A&R are the way to go with all the positive feedback. Korby...My holders bottom on the Super 7 top-slide, but I only use 8mm tooling so is not a problem. The QCTH block would have to be quite a bit bigger to allow the holder to pass the edge of the top-slide. Can anyone identify the supplier from the photo of the box above, I'm just curious... Regards Phil
Edited By CotswoldsPhil on 27/01/2015 11:07:37 |
Michael Briggs | 27/01/2015 19:42:22 |
221 forum posts 12 photos | Hello Phil, I can identify the box as Toolmex, I have a chuck for my Myford that has a similar style label, I also have a toolpost that is of later manufacture, the box is blue labelled with the same part numbers as above but branded Bison. The quality and fit are excellent, I have some Weston holders, A&R and they all fit perfectly. Regards, Michael |
CotswoldsPhil | 27/01/2015 19:53:16 |
![]() 196 forum posts 112 photos | Hi Michael, This Forum is indeed a mine of information... Thanks for identifying the supplier, the QCTH appear nicely made and all work well, so I will look to get some holders from A&R when they next advertise a batch. Regards
Phil H |
"Bill Hancox" | 27/01/2015 21:39:43 |
![]() 257 forum posts 77 photos | Posted by CotswoldsPhil on 26/01/2015 13:56:06:
Can you help me identify which QC toolholder I have acquired? When I bought the Super 7 at the end of last year it came with a basic QCTH set. The tool-post fits the top-slide clamp stud perfectly. I have the original box (see photo below), the 2 tool-holders are engraved with the part number 4494-48, and appear hardened. PhilI have a similar tool post. Can anyone tell me what that extra hole is for? And don't try to tell me that it is a holder for a hand-held mobile graphite communicator (pencil). Cheers Bill |
Mike Poole | 27/01/2015 21:48:54 |
![]() 3676 forum posts 82 photos | Many Dickson toolposts have a pin fitted in the hole, I suspect it may be dowel to locate the toolpost on the top slide. Mike |
Clive Foster | 27/01/2015 22:30:13 |
3630 forum posts 128 photos | Bill The Dickson T2 triple mount holder that came with my Pratt & Whitney model B had a very OEM looking sliding locating pin in the equivalent hole which appeared to be intended to allow the post to be returned to its normal alignment should the user need to rotate it for any reason. Given that the thing was well rust'n age fitted and that Messrs Pratt & Whitney had not seen fit to provide anywhere suitable on the topslide for a matching hole I suspect that it came inserted from the factory and had never been moved. I've seen a reasonable sample of Dickson type posts over the years in various sizes and that's the only one having anything in the hole. Unless you count spiders, swarf, cutting oil, dust and other contamination. Could be useful as a mount for a dial gauge carrier assembly. An expanding collett or O ring device to hold a stud or short post onto which the actual carrier gubbins could easily be fitted when needed should not be too hard to arrange. Limited rotation angle of the locking cam can be due to poor fit of the height setting collar in the grooved section below the locking drive nut. On the T2 series there is enough variation in collar diameter, thickness and glove depth between various quality (European & UK) brands to prevent universal interchange out of the box. I have some 5 or 6 varieties in my collection. Dickson appear to have the deepest collars, Rapid the shallowest. Something over 20 thou difference so everything will fit Dickson but modifications are needed to Rapid. I diamond filed out the top of the groove. worth checking if same applies to smaller sizes. Had to trim the diameter of one collar too. Given that everything is solid I don't think the locking mechanism can actually go over centre. As I recall matters the larger Dickson merely goes close to 90°. Hafta look at end of year clean-up time. Presumably there is an angle close enough to 90° that holds despite not actually going over. Grot inside seriously reduces performance. I clean and wipe lube mine every year. Given the small clearances its amazing how much stuff gets in. At least its easy to keep the mounting faces clean when in use. Clive |
NJH | 27/01/2015 23:15:26 |
![]() 2314 forum posts 139 photos | Yes Michael is correct here - it is for a dowel to align the toolpost with a hole drilled in the topside. The dowel pin will have a "knob" turned on the outer end to allow its removal and rotation of the post to another position where required. Norman |
"Bill Hancox" | 27/01/2015 23:27:44 |
![]() 257 forum posts 77 photos | Thank you gentlemen. I appreciate your assistance. Your comments are certainly in line with my assumptions. I may put your information to use on a raising block that I am building. Cheers Bill |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.