Searching for design by George Punter in ME
Howard Lewis | 15/01/2018 13:35:39 |
7227 forum posts 21 photos | A thought that has just come to me. Scaling the nozzle holes would entail drilling holes about 0.02 mm dia, which will be difficult. And, to compensate for the poorer atomisation resulting from a lower injection pressure (probably originally circa 1,000 psi - 680 bar) why not increase the compression ratio, to improve the chances of initiating combustion? This may well mean retarding the injection timing a little, but should reduce ignition delay, and so make the engine a little quieter. Howard |
Monoman | 15/01/2018 14:26:37 |
51 forum posts 7 photos | I'm pleased that this topic has raised so much interest and so many thoughtful contributions. I don’t think I want to comment further on the various historic ignition processes. My concern really is with building an operating model which should be capable of powering an Excavator. The 3 VQBN was specifically developed to power the Ruston-Bucyrus 19-RB. As Howard has mentioned noise' part of my wish is to end up with a machine which has the atmosphere of the original, which probably means the noise as well. I have used the ME Index thoughtfully supplied by Phil (Weary) and there are several entries in volumes 210 and 211 about George Punter’s Lister build. I believe that his earlier 4 cylinder engine may relate more to my hopes. The video of it is at On the assumption that I will eventually produce a working model I will be only too pleased to shoe it here. Jerry |
Roger B | 15/01/2018 14:41:59 |
![]() 244 forum posts 105 photos | Howard, I felt that trying to produce a multi hole injector in this size would be extremely difficult and at a high risk of getting blocked. I am using a pintle type with a hole of 0.35mm which appears to give god atomisation at around 60 Bar. The other consideration is that the combustion chamber will be smaller so less penetration will be required. I doo have a concern that the fuel will just end up on top of the piston.
|
LADmachining | 17/01/2018 10:30:52 |
![]() 126 forum posts 11 photos | A construction article for 'DUX' - a 9.5cc single cylinder Diesel with solid fuel injection, designed by Martin Alewijn - appeared in Strictly IC magazine from Dec 2000/Jan 2001 to Aug/Sep 2001 (issues 78 to 82). I understand that back issues of the magazine are still available from the publisher at www.strictlyic.com. As I recall from the article, the issue of drilling a very small hole in injector was avoided by making a very fine scratch in the conical seat of the injector needle, which then provided a path for the fuel and the necessary atomisation. Anthony Edited By LADmachining on 17/01/2018 10:32:10 |
Roger B | 19/01/2018 07:43:32 |
![]() 244 forum posts 105 photos | Going back to the original question: How big is the engine going to be? The one in the video is around 30mm bore and 38mm stroke. (it wasn't built by George Punter, but by W7CS. It's just liked on George's YouTube). The horizontal valves suggest that the engine you want to build has a clearstory combustion chamber which should make things a little easier. The injection pump on the engine in the video is ~4mm bore and ~2mm stroke. This seems rather big unless he is allowing for a lot of leakage. Injection pressure is ~80Bar which is the range I am trying to achieve. If you go ahead with this I would suggest that you make a bar stock single cylinder version to learn and experiment on. Best regards Roger |
Monoman | 19/01/2018 09:06:00 |
51 forum posts 7 photos | Hi Roger, Thanks for your notes. I have been following your 2 threads on MEM about you investigativr work. I'm afraid I am rather late to this particular party. On MEM I have a 'new' thread which is rather scanty at the moment as I am just at the design stage of my 19-RB project. As to size that's not yet determined; it can only be as big as the model which it is to power will allow and the size of that depends on how much room it will take up in the workshop. You will see that on this site the thread has been diverted into a debate about definitions of the term 'Diesel' which whilst being interesting has no value to me in trying to build a miniature version of a Ruston & Hornsby machine. My understanding is that R-H machines were 'solid injection' which they described as 'airless injection'. Jerry |
Four stroke Fred | 12/03/2018 22:40:54 |
![]() 322 forum posts 305 photos | The model Lister 6/1 Diesel engine is a diesel in that it does not have any form of spark ignition and relies on compression for instigating the combustion process. It is a four stroke engine and does use an injector pump with a manual by pass valve. The injector made use of a modified gas jet and injects into a pre combustion chamber as does the full size engine. I have only ever made one single cylinder Diesel engine but have made 29 other petrol engines from 6.5 cc to 150 cc , singles ,twins, threes and four cylinders. As you can see my experience of Diesel engine construction is limited and it is a continuous learning process but if I can help you Jerry in any way I will be pleased to do so. George Punter. |
Monoman | 20/03/2018 11:49:04 |
51 forum posts 7 photos | Thank You George ( Four Stroke Fred), Sorry I have been so slow in responding to your post of the 12th, I had to search back through several pages of previous posts to reach it. It seems the ME forum has been very busy during the past 8 days ! Your offer is very welcome as yours seems to be the only example I can find of anyone building a successful in-line diesel engine. I am not sure that I made it clear in my earlier posts that I am building a replica of a Ruston-Bucyrus shovel, at the moment the R-B machine is not at all certain as it will in the end depend on the availability of detailed informattion. However since the last steam machine was sold in the 1930's every one has been available with Diesel power. A I am sure you know Rustons supplied Ruston engines until the partnership with Bucyrus ended but my understanding is that Ruston and Lister engines were similar in many ways. As you have been successful in getting your engine to work I am certain you could provide me with assistance in many areas, especially fuel injection. I will send you a PM Best regards Jerry |
not done it yet | 20/03/2018 14:02:00 |
7517 forum posts 20 photos | “ I had to search back through several pages of previous posts to reach it.” A tip. Go to ‘My Posts’ and it will show your posts. Alternatively, search for the thread topic. Far easier than trawling through pages of posts/threads.
|
Four stroke Fred | 21/03/2018 07:56:10 |
![]() 322 forum posts 305 photos | Jerry I have only ever made the single cylinder Diesel engine but have seen a four cylinder working model some where on the forum or YouTube. My approach to making model I.C. Engines has always been from a practical point of view and not so much on the " theory". In my book if the I.C. engine works and it doesn't have a spark plug to ignite the mixture, it is a Diesel engine! The difficult parts to make are the injector and injector pump as most if the other parts are similar in structure to any other four stroke petrol engine. My main problem was the injector jet hole and on my engine I used a gas jet. George. |
martin perman | 21/03/2018 09:17:47 |
![]() 2095 forum posts 75 photos | Posted by Howard Lewis on 15/01/2018 12:49:18:
If you want to see an example of Dr Rudolph Diesel's engine, made by Sulzer in 1913, visit The Museum of Internal Fire, near Aberystwyth. If you are lucky, they may even set it running, (takes about 10 minutes to build up air pressure for starting and injection). Gentlemen, I used to regularly volunteer at Internal Fire Museum of Power and have an amusing tale about the Sulzer, when Paul Evans was setting up the Museum he was approached by an Electricity Company who asked if was interested in an old water pump at one of their sites so he went along to have a look and found that they were offering the Sulzer as the old pump, Paul couldn't believe his eyes as there are only a couple left and his is the only one in the UK. As already stated it takes a while to get the compressed air up to pressure to start and then there is a lot of lever pulling before it will run on its own but its a lovely engine. The Museum can be found in the village of Tan y Groes half way between Aberystwyth and Cardigan. Martin P
|
Bob Rodgerson | 21/03/2018 15:41:24 |
612 forum posts 174 photos | I made a 22 cc compression ignition four stroke engine with variable compression ratio controlled by moving the crankshaft up and down. For fuelI used a mix of paraffin with 10% lube oil and about 1-2% easy start. It was successful and flew a model aircraft quite well. It has a lovely sound especially when opening the throttle with a very distinct Diesel Knock. I displayed it in a model at Elvington about 1999, quite a number of people who thought they knew it all told me that my engine needed looking at because you could hear the big end knocking. it f I'm not saying how I moved the crank shaft up and down but will leave you guessing. |
Four stroke Fred | 21/03/2018 20:49:48 |
![]() 322 forum posts 305 photos | Bob I think you you may have made a non concentric crankshaft bearing that when rotated raised or lowered the con rod,piston unit. I remember seeing a model aircraft flying near Malborough ( Wiltshire) with a commercial prototype four stroke Diesel engine and that used a variable compression unit in the position where the spark plug would have gone - it also sounded good. George. |
Bob Rodgerson | 21/03/2018 22:40:28 |
612 forum posts 174 photos | You are on the right track Fred. It would only be possible to do this with a vertical or possibly Vee formation engine. |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.