By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

Using 3D prints for casting

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
Chris Pattison 118/02/2015 03:00:37
21 forum posts

Here in NZ, if I were to order castings from the UK, not only will these be very costly, but I suspect that their shipping weight will add substantial cost to their purchase. So, with the advent of 3D printing, I wonder if anybody has explored making patterns for either sand casting or lost-wax casting of parts? In the long run, these 3D programs could be exchanged across the world at minimal cost.

David Jupp18/02/2015 07:32:44
978 forum posts
26 photos

3D printing of patterns, and direct 3D printing of wax is becoming commonplace in commercial casting.

Compared to hiring a pattern maker, 3D printing is quick and relatively cheap. The 3D file can very easily be derived from CAD design files - a scaling operation and add draft where required.

Michael Gilligan18/02/2015 08:39:56
avatar
23121 forum posts
1360 photos
Posted by David Jupp on 18/02/2015 07:32:44:

... direct 3D printing of wax is becoming commonplace in commercial casting.

.

David,

That's very good to know ... especially as [in 2013] we were discussing 'direct 3D printing of wax' as a possibility.

'Hope' to 'Commodity' in less than two years.

MichaelG.

.

Edit: added link to the earlier thread.

 

Edited By Michael Gilligan on 18/02/2015 08:41:55

JasonB18/02/2015 08:52:11
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

David, what sort of cost would one be looking at to print out say a set of castings like these, thats a 6" flywheel for size. I know what they cost me to get shipped from the US, cost of casting would be comprable in either case.

imag3035.jpg

I know of a few Builders in Australia that have made their own patterns or fabricated the simpler parts but still found it more cost effective to have the complicated castings like cylinders shipped fropm the UK. Also know of a crake containing about a tonne of castings that has recently arrived over there.

Peter Bond18/02/2015 09:06:54
65 forum posts
8 photos

The Solidscape range of printers has been around for quite a long time; they're effectively glorified inkjet printers that use wax rather than ink. They give some fantastic results, but I've heard a few owners say they can be a bit twitchy, particularly if only used intermittently.

Wax milling through CNC remains popular - the claim is that the surface finish exceeds anything you'll get from a printer.

SLA resins exist that can be burned out as part of the lost wax process; they don't handle exactly like wax though, so need fairly specific handling.

Lost PLA casting has been done; last I read about it there tended to be a moderate amount of ash.

Sand casting using the printed model is possible - on a small scale it can be done with Delft clay.

My interest is focussed on the small-scale stuff, so sub-mm features and build volumes in the order of 40x70x100mm max.

Neil Wyatt18/02/2015 09:09:42
avatar
19226 forum posts
749 photos
86 articles

An interesting topic as some foundries won't touch this idea with a bargepole, while a few others are happily doing it.

I have someone who is in conversation with a foundry specifically with the aim of producing an article that not only describes HOW you can do this, but also will give readers an idea of WHERE they can get the castings done.

Neil

David Jupp18/02/2015 09:09:50
978 forum posts
26 photos

Sorry - can't help with pricing of 3D prints. Depends on system used, how you factor the capital cost of the printer, size, any support materials needed in the print process.

One way to get a feel for price would be to upload part files to one of the bureau services that now abound. That would obviously include delivery and a profit margin.

For fine scale stuff - optical or inkjet based systems are probably the way to go, for larger stuff fused filament printers might be OK.  There are a few 'castable resins' or waxes available.

Edited By David Jupp on 18/02/2015 09:18:17

Paul Lousick18/02/2015 09:40:35
2276 forum posts
801 photos

Hi Chris,

I live in Sydney and had a similar problem to you with shipping. Originally, I ordered most of the castings for my engine from a supplier in the UK. They weighed about 250 kg and cost me about $700 for shipping which I considered reasonable. Unfortunately I did not include a casting which is required for my engine. This casting weighs approx 30 kg and sells for about $150, BUT the cost of shipping by sea was quoted at more that $200. I asked if it could be sent by air freight and was told that it would be more expensive.

Apparently heavy items like the casting has to be packaged in a large wooden box and fumigated before it is shipped. The box that I originally received was about 900 x 900 x 900 and was only 1/4 full. (probably so it could be handled by a forklift). It is the cost of the and handling fees which add to the cost. OK for large quantities but not for small numbers. I am now fabricating the part instead of using a casting.

3D printed patterns and having then cast is a good option, especially for 1-off castings made from wax.

Paul.

HomeUse18/02/2015 09:45:39
avatar
168 forum posts
12 photos

I have been experimenting with direct extrusion of wax but the problems i have encountered have been trying to cool (solidify) the wax quick enough after the hothead so as to retain its shape and not “sag” - At the moment the extruder is hand worked as the full printer is not completed. - A fellow experimenter is developing the idea of producing 3d printed (plastic) moulds into which wax can be injected for lost wax casting - this can become complicated if there are a lot of undercuts.

JasonB18/02/2015 10:24:49
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

One problem I see with using printed parts as the master or to burn/melt out is that nowhere is there a button on a CAD package that gives you the experience of a good pattern maker.

If you print out the item as you want it to look with scale, draft and machining allowance added then have it printed in say wax and then cast what happens if there is excessive shrinkage in a bulky part that a good pattern maker would have forseen and added extra material or larger gates to fill this part as it cools.

Now with a wooden pattern at least you get a second chance as you can add a bit to it or just cast it again in sand with suitable feeders. If burning or melting it you would have to print the part again.

J

David Jupp18/02/2015 10:47:54
978 forum posts
26 photos

Agreed Jason - you can use a 3D printed pattern like a wooden pattern if surface finish is good enough (either straight from printer or with some 'post processing' ) , you are not forced to go down the burn out route.

Edited By David Jupp on 18/02/2015 10:48:13

JasonB18/02/2015 12:03:49
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

Well did a quick look at costings from a couple of googled sources. Based on just one 6" flywheel

Sent a STL file to one with instant online quote, choice of colours, done on Ultimakers, from photos on their site looks quite basic quality but came in at £101.

Using a basic guide for the volume on another site in white nylon with a good quality surface finish cost would be £112.50.

Given that I got that whole set of castings posted from the states for $105 it may just work out a bit cheaper if I want a poor finish on the parts.

EDITED a sI sent an imperial file not metric so the 6.99 flywheel wil actually be 101.00

Edited By JasonB on 18/02/2015 12:24:38

Ennech18/02/2015 12:15:11
avatar
153 forum posts
143 photos

If you are concerned about the shipping weight I would suggest that for such size parts you would be even more concerned about the cost of 3D printing whether direct wax printing or or 3D printing a pattern. 3D printing is affordable for small items but for larger patterns CNC machining is more cost effective. I would also suggest that there is more to making foundry patterns than just converting a 3D CAD file to stl form and making the pattern directly from it. There is a degree of know how involved.

Eric

David Jupp18/02/2015 12:17:21
978 forum posts
26 photos

Cost can be potentially be reduced by making inside of pattern a structural mesh rather than solid - uses less material, so can be cheaper with some printing processes. Unfortunately that's a bit 'fancy' to attempt on many CAD systems. Design tools need to evolve a bit to take best advantage of 3D printing.

Ketan Swali18/02/2015 12:20:31
1481 forum posts
149 photos

Jason,

Costs for shipping into USA and out of the USA into UK are reasonably cheap.

Sending goods to Australia and New Zealand is expensive, be it by sea or by courier/air, and then it gets worse if the person lives in an 'out of zone' area = more rural Australian or New Zaland region.

For sea freight into Australia, there is fumigation process to be costed in if using solid wood. Plywood or any other material packaging does not need it in case of engineering goods/casting.

Sea freight is calculated per 1CBM or 1 Metric ton, which ever is the greater, and then the other handling shipping and clearance charges are applicable.

For New Zealand, almost every courier parcel gets stopped by their customs nowadays!....adding to the delay.

Ketan at ARC.

Edited By Ketan Swali on 18/02/2015 12:21:46

Ketan Swali18/02/2015 12:24:19
1481 forum posts
149 photos

Jason,

Sorry I forgot to add:

In other words, keeping above transport costs in mind, I can see why they would want to consider 3D printed parts. Do not know if it would still be cost effective though.

Ketan at ARC.

Neil Wyatt18/02/2015 12:26:28
avatar
19226 forum posts
749 photos
86 articles

I've seen acetone-fumed 3D prints and the surface finish is almost like glass, alternatively I've seen the surface finish left by a quick going over with wet and dry paper, and it looks plenty good enough for sand casting to me.

Neil

David Jupp18/02/2015 12:31:40
978 forum posts
26 photos

In industry, some foundries miss out the pattern all together and 3D print the sand mould shell directly.

JasonB18/02/2015 12:34:52
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

Parcel Force website quotes £199 to send 20kg down under which is more than that whole set of castings weighs but the same money would only buy me two flywheel prints so does not seem economical if out sourcing the printing.

Printing your own would become more cost effective with the more parts you print as that will even out the cost of a printer.

J

Ennech18/02/2015 12:37:13
avatar
153 forum posts
143 photos

Yes but if you are talking about sand printing for making castings you will have A BIG surprise at the cost. It is only cost effective for small cores that would be difficult to make by conventional means

Eric

On the subject of shipping costs.....I wonder how ever the Chinese can be so rich shipping their stuff all over the world!

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Sign up to our Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
cowells
Sarik
MERIDIENNE EXHIBITIONS LTD
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest

 

Donate

donate