By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more

Member postings for Bill Pudney

Here is a list of all the postings Bill Pudney has made in our forums. Click on a thread name to jump to the thread.

Thread: Open Source models
12/05/2012 22:11:30

How about providing a set of drawings linked to MEW. Following the "Engineering for Beginners" series by Mick Knights for instance.

Everyone needs to start somewhere, and we all need decent toolmakers clamps, calipers, odds and ends.

cheers

Bill Pudney

Thread: Aircraft General Discussion
01/05/2012 11:49:05

Michael Williams asked about working on Hovercraft. Crikey where do I start?? In 1964 when I started there, hovercraft were out of the experimental stage, and getting into the development stage. In fact they were pretty much in that until after I left in 1969.

Saunders Roe were basically an aircraft company (remember the Princess flying boat, SR53 rocket/jet experimental interceptor....M2.2 climbing at 45 degrees!! and the Black Knight rocket) so obviously their Hovercraft used a lot of aircraft techniques in construction.

In 1964 the Big Thing that I was aware of was skirt development. At the time (hovercraft) skirts weren't very flexible, and had a very short life and involved a very high level of maintenance. The skirt material would delaminate and flog itself to shreds. In the building next to the dormitory I was in (Saunders Roe was in East Cowes on the Isle of Wight, and they maintained an Apprentice Hostel for their mainland Apprentices) was the wind tunnel. Attached to the out side of that building was something called a "Flapping Rig" where samples of skirt material could be flapped to death, At the beginning skirt material would last maybe 1 hour, Avon (the tyre company) developed a thin, flexible, relatively light material. It took two or three years, but eventually the Flapping Rig was running continuously. Technically this was a great achievement, but the rig was very noisy...imagine a piece of neoprene/cloth laminations three feet by two feet or thereabouts and 2.5mm thick flapping in an 80 knot breeze! We were expected to sleep forty feet away from it.

Then there was the story of training Hovercraft pilots. When performing a turn Hovercraft drift downwind, so when performing consequtive 360 degree turns you can imagine that the hovercrafts course would look a bit like a spring. So there was the hovercraft with it's Middle East Trainee Pilot, doing consecutive 360 degree turns, drifting slowly down on a bloke fishing from a small dinghy, it was the Solent after all. The instructor a bit concerned asks trainee if trainee had seen the fisherman,

"Yes" says trainee,

"Are you going to take avoiding action" says Instructor

"No, its only a fisherman" says Trainee, whereupon Instructor takes over control.

When SRN4-001 was finished, before she could start flight trials the Board of Trade required that she complete a 24 hour full power tethered trial. This was started on a Saturday and could be heard all over Cowes, East and West. Now four Proteus gas turbines, driving four 19 foot diameter paddle blade props, and four huge fans makes a lot of noise, but I don't recall any complaints.

Then there was the story about the SRN4 when on test flights. The story goes something like.....

SRN4-001 was on trials in the Channel, some way South of the IOW, when up comes an RN Patrol Boat. There was some confusion as to whether it was a "Dark" Class boat or "Tenacity", but anyway. Being very polite the RN Skipper asks of the hovercraft "everything ok", sees that all is indeed ok and starts to accelerate away. Whereupon the SRN4 accelerated up to its maximum speed (which was well over its Board of Trade limited speed, but that hadn't been imposed yet) and flew past the patrol boat. It was apparently that trip that the Hovercraft achieved its highest speed, something over 80 knots.

In the Machine Shop was a huge long skinny mill, the bed of which was probably over 70 feet long which was used for machining wing spars. It was designed and built to machine the wing spars for the Princess. This machine was installed in the corner of the shop, closest to the sea wall, which was probably about 40 feet away. I assumed that the tide tables on the wall were for general interest, but no. The tidal rise and fall made the bed move up and down, and the only operator who could make any sense of it, apparently used to suck his teeth, pull his chin and mutter, then as the straddle mill was working its way down the bed would crank in a bit here and crank out a bit there....amazing.

Anyway its past my bedtime

cheers

Bill Pudney

30/04/2012 01:54:11

Michael Williams asked if anyone had personal experience of the Redux process. When I did my apprenticeship way back in the '60's the company was making hovercraft. Most of the large panels were stiffened by the the use of folded stringers of witches hat section bonded to large flat sheets which were up to 8 feet long. At the time we were told that they were bonded using the Redux process, which was (we were told) an epoxy based adhesive. The stringers had the adhesive applied by roller, they were placed in position, an "anti-tear" pop rivet placed at each end of the stringer, the whole assembly was then placed in a press which applied heat and pressure. Test samples were made of each adhesive mix, and after curing were subjected to a standard peel test. After curing the hollow stringers were filled with expanding two part foam. The bigger panels were full sheet size, I suppose 8' x 4', from memory (it was all nearly 50 years ago) and had a stringer about every 6 or 8". The panel and stringer material thickness was about 18swg (0.048" ? thick) the whole panels were as stiff as a really stiff thing and very light.

If you can find any pictures of an SRN4 hovercraft, pretty much the whole exterior utilised these panels.

I've just put "Redux Process" into Wikipedia, it's worth a look!!

cheers

Bill Pudney

Thread: Taps - What material?
27/04/2012 06:10:58

I agree that HSS is better. Also look for "ground thread" taps. Most "name" manufacturers grind taps

In my experience all carbon steel taps have gashed flutes which leave burrs on the threaded portion. How a reasonably accurate thread can then be generated is a mystery to me.

Also for what its worth, I would suggest that buying a set of taps be avoided. Better to buy good quality taps as and when you need them.

Finally avoid second hand taps, unless they are clearly unused.

cheers

Bill Pudney

Thread: Thread forming taps
28/02/2012 03:45:05

When I had to work for a living we had to make some satellite bits out of grades 2 and 4 Titanium. The parts had lots (dozens per part) of M1 threads. Conventional very high quality cutting taps were lasting maybe two threads, they usually broke after two, so we developed some expertise in getting the bits out! Someone suggested thread forming taps. They were imported from Germany, and they worked a treat, but they were very, very expensive. Taps would typically last 30 to 40 threads from memory.

cheers

Bill Pudney

Thread: Permanently bonding Aluminium
19/12/2011 02:10:09
I second Ramons suggestion of JB Weld. I have a 2.5cc diesel engine with a piston held together with JB Weld. It has a claimed max operating temp of something like 250degrees C. My motor has been in use with its epoxied piston for about 4 years now with absolutely no problems.
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: chineese mills
06/11/2011 02:41:33
For what its worth, at different times I got both my Sieg C3 Mini Lathe and X2 Mini Mill from Minitech. The freight costs of both machines has disappeared in the mists of time, but in neither case did I think "Gordon Bennett". Their support has been good as well. I have been thinking about replacing the C3 with a C4, and if Minitech showed it on their website I would go straight to them, maybe a phone call is in order!!
The choice up here in Australia is a bit limited compared to what we see in England and the US. Just yesterday I had to get an MT3 Dead Centre from the local Hare and Forbes agents and it cost $42, at which point I did say "Gordon Bennett"
cheers
Bill Pudney
 
Thread: Why not Make Two?
25/10/2011 01:14:58
When I had to work for a living, Manufacturing were often asked to make one or two of something. The expensive bit about our manufacturing was the "Non recurring" effort, drawing, planning, programming etc. Unless the required material was something exotic, material cost was pretty low as well, although the lead time for material could be weeks (remember this is Australia).
So when it seemed like a good idea I would often double or triple the engineers requirement.
The additional cost of the extra material and machine time was minimal and easily absorbed.
So when the opportunity to double or triple up arises its well worth while, and might even provide additional income via a sale!!
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: 5 CC CI engine (and a bit of a Grump)
07/10/2011 04:02:46
Don't fret about missing drawing "whoopsies" Ramon. When I was a Draftsman I found it close to impossible to spot my own mistakes. We used to add 30% as a "checking allowance" to D.O. estimates.
One prototype project I was involved in was creating a huge amount of grief from the Workshop Manager, he was saying that my drawings were no good and full of errors. Purely in my own defence I went through each of about 200 drawings, added up all the dimensions and compared them to the known errors. The actual error rate was under three percent. At the time in the standard (DEF AUS 5085 I seem to remember) the permitted error rate was five percent. As the Workshop Manager had been spreading my perceived incompetance up to CEO level, I took some pleasure in writing a memo to the person concerned and copying it to my boss and the CEO to explain the facts.
No more problems!!
cheers
Bill Pudney

Edited By Bill Pudney on 07/10/2011 04:03:51

Thread: 5cc CI engine and diesel fuel
22/09/2011 01:06:52
Up here in Australia it can be a challenge getting the components for diesel fuel, however it can be done.
The big one of course is ether. Here in Adelaide we have at least two places, however one is three times the cost of the other!! Both are chemical supply concerns.
Kero/paraffin, the favourite used to be the locally packaged blue dyed stuff available in hardware stores, but they changed suppliers recently and the current stuff is unreliable. So I got some jet fuel!! At the local airfield locate the fuel supplier and get JetA1, its generally cheaper than the hardware store stuff and of a uniform quality. You do need to take your own bucket though.
Oil....Castrol M from the local Castrol agent
Ignition improver, where we used to use Amyl Nitrate/nitrite, nowadays they are replaced by IPN (Iso Propyl Nitrate???) which is VERY expensive (approx $110 per 500ml, but it does last a long time!!). However a few years ago I lucked into an alternative.....Amsoil Cetane Booster, about $15 per 300 odd ml. Google "Amsoil Cetane Booster" to discover your local supplier. F2C Team Racers may be able to detect the difference between IPN and Amsoil, but normal users will not detect a difference.
There we are, its all available if you hunt around, at least here in the wide brown land.
Your ETAs are beautiful Ramon!! Keep up the good work.
cheers
Bill Pudney
Adelaide, Australia
 
 
Thread: Hacksaw blade tension
12/09/2011 06:19:26
I seem to remember from my apprenticeship that it was....take the slack off then three turns of the wing nut.
Its worked for me for the last 45 years.
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: digital tv switchover
19/08/2011 05:08:06
It's a real shame that despite all the complex engineering involved, the commercial freeview digital channels here in Australia are showing such a load of old, repeated, not at all good, rubbish. Seventeen channels in total, and about twelve channels of digital drivel!
Sorry if its OT
Bill Pudney
Thread: Toughen heat resistance adhesive.
13/08/2011 02:22:12
"J B Weld" might do the trick. Its intended for metal to metal, and is rated up to something like 300 degrees. I've used it for sticking a bit of al. alloy to the balsa leading edge of a model aeroplane, where the balsa can get charred by the hot exhaust without the al. alloy. I've also used J B Weld to glue a diesel engine piston together (!!), it will be flown for the umpteenth time later today.
best of luck!!
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: What happened to the conclusion of CNC 4th Axis?
06/08/2011 02:33:16
It seems to me that expecting "perfect" (i.e. professionally prepared and peer reviewed) articles is a bit much in what is essentially a hobby magazine. Certainly the author should include the design specification, which would include the "not required to rotate whilst cutting" in the case of the 4th Axis in question. For me part of the enjoyment is to take an article as a kick off point for my own contrivances, so any inaccuracies or errors are irrelevant.
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: What happened to the Myford sale thread?
20/07/2011 06:29:16
"Then imagine how many machines and jigs would be needed to make this old school.

John S."
 
John S is spot on there. When I had to work for a living the place where I spent my time made some very complex parts. Some of them required up to 18 different operations and many changes from lathe to mill to the fitting bench and back again, there were inummerable small jigs and fixtures as well. All with their own inspection stages and opportunities for stuff ups. Then we got a new machine that did everything....bar stock in, finished part out, no jigs, no fixtures, one (big!) inspection stage, the machine paid itself back in under twelve months from memory. Those parts were not required in huge numbers, from memory batches of six or eight prevailed.
 
Given a robust well proven data pack (this may require several prototypes to sort out drawing issues), a workshop or workshops with the appropriate machinery there is no reason why a competent range of small/medium, widely specified lathes and maybe mills could not be made for a sensible price. The issue then is to match the design and manufacturing sophistication (and therefore the retail price) to the anticipated market.
Interesting discussion!!
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: No 4407 More Errors
03/07/2011 03:55:15
My better half told me that pedantry is dead.
This thread proves her wrong.
 
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: New I/C diesel project - ETA15d-x2
28/06/2011 01:41:11
Beautiful Ramon, just beautiful.
Can't wait to hear how they run.
I've thoroughly enjoyed your story, and the Racer one before it.
Once again beautiful work!!
best regards
Bill Pudney
09/05/2011 01:02:37
This is all really interesting Ramon, keep up the good work!!
 
About the woodruffe cutter for the exhaust ports.....is the cutter just secured to the arbor with a socket head screw?
cheers
Bill Pudney
Thread: Technical and engineering drawing.
20/04/2011 01:10:12
Hi David,
About a survey. Those of us up here in Australasia get the magazines some weeks or months after publication in the UK. As a result the closing date for returning surveys is usually long gone. So can you either
 
1/ Have a later closing date to suit responses from overseas
 
or
 
2/ Have an online poll
 
cheers
Bill Pudney
in sunny Adelaide
19/04/2011 01:00:18
Hello chaps,
This is a very interesting debate. However I think that a fundamental point has been missed. That point is, that a drawing should enable someone to make something.
cheers
Bill Pudney
Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Sign up to our Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
cowells
Sarik
MERIDIENNE EXHIBITIONS LTD
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest

 

Donate

donate