By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

16mm IDRIS

Is anyone else going to try this model ?

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
martin ranson 212/06/2015 13:48:44
avatar
135 forum posts
2 photos

IDRIS DRAWING ERROR ... in part 4 of the series, at the bottom of page 872 is figure 16 ... there are 3 references to 7 BA threads ... these should read 6 BA ... the text alongside the drawing correctly reads 6 BA ... cannot blame the gremlins for this one ... my fault.

martin

Alex Collins12/06/2015 22:27:08
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

Hi Martin. I had already worked that one out. I have 6 BA screws and they all fit as expected.
I will comment that this makes the crank pin bushes very thin. I may go up a bit on the ID of the bushes.

Alex Collins16/06/2015 19:04:28
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

img_1049.jpg

Alex Collins16/06/2015 19:57:08
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

I'm wondering where the text went that was with the photo....

4 wheels started.

Boss is 16mm dia X 11mm long. may well reduce this later. It's 16mm cos I have a 16mm Collet.

I turned the boss taking ~ 2mm cuts down to 17mm dia then cleaned it all up. The myford was quite happy with this.
Parted them off at 7mm with a 2mm wide tool. It really didn't like that much.
The tool dug in several times during each cut. The clutch I fitted has proven most valuable.
Tried everything including regrinding the tool.

I'll put the boss into the Collet chuck to drill the hole and turn the tread. That should keep it all concentric.
What sort of angles do I need on the flange and tread ?

martin ranson 217/06/2015 08:22:24
avatar
135 forum posts
2 photos

Morning Alex ... welcome back ... wow ! a 2 mm cut in steel is very impressive, I am pretty sure my small lathe would be struggling ... how far away from the chuck were you cutting when doing the parting-off ?

As regards the angles on the wheels ... I am not the worlds best expert on railway practices ... what I have found out varies with who I ask ... the angle between the tread and the flange is a bit bigger than 90 degrees ... the tread is not parallel, it is slightly coned by about 3 - 6 degrees ... the flange is not vertical, it is tipped inwards towards the middle of the track by 6 - 14 degrees, typically 10 degrees ... where the tread meets the flange is sometimes a sharp corner and sometimes a very small radius, about 0. 5 to 1mm ... the flange depth for 32 mm seems to be about 2 - 3 mm.

If all else fails, try and measure the commercial wheels you have bought ... hope this is some use.

martin

John Bromley17/06/2015 11:59:26
84 forum posts
The standards for wheel profiles are on the 16mm narrow gauge modellers website.
I believe they are under downloads.
John
Alex Collins17/06/2015 18:16:08
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

Hi Martin.

I cut off 100 mm of bar. That gave me enough for 4 wheels + the option of a 5th.
For the first 2 I used a steady + the centre. The 2nd pair I ditched the centre.

Cleaned the lathe tonight. The parting issues were probably caused by the lash in the cross slide getting sucked in.
I'll add in a bit of friction on the slide locks next time....

John. Will wonder over to that site and have a look.

Thanks

martin ranson 218/06/2015 06:56:17
avatar
135 forum posts
2 photos

Alex ... just a P.S. to my words above ... some of the commercial wheels I bought a few years ago only had a small flange ... I did not realise at the time ... the depth was less than 1. 5 mm ( actually 0. 055 inches ) ... the wagon with those wheels would occasionally leap skywards passing over a point ... problem ceased when I managed to re-cut the flange a bit deeper ...maybe 2 mm is a decent minimum depth ?

I have just been given a long list of jobs from SWMBO, so I will be busy for a few days ... have to turn the lathe off for a while !!! horror !!! back soon.

martin

Alex Collins21/06/2015 18:59:26
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

105.jpgWheels complete. Just need to drill and tap for the grub screws.
104.jpg

Steven Greenhough22/06/2015 06:53:57
144 forum posts
54 photos
Wheels look good Alex.
Alex Collins23/06/2015 18:50:46
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

You may have to forgive me this one.
Fig 17, Page 873.
The drawing for the eccentric says:
Throw 0.236
Center offset half of this = 0.118
That's fine.
I get a bit of round bar Offset it by 0.118.

What size round bar do I start with ? ( or what size is the lobe )

JasonB23/06/2015 18:59:03
avatar
25215 forum posts
3105 photos
1 articles

0.625" - 5/8"

There is a clue written just under the big bold "Eccentric" printwink 2

Alex Collins23/06/2015 20:47:02
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

DOH!
Thankyou Jason

martin ranson 227/06/2015 11:12:12
avatar
135 forum posts
2 photos

Morning Alex ... like the look of the 4 wheels ... I do not know if this is any use to you ... the commercial wheels I bought had a thickness of approx. 0. 474 inches ( 12. 03 mm ? ) ... they were not all exactly the same ... I varied the size of the bearing bushes to match the individual wheels ... you may have to do something similar ... I positioned the wheels at the correct distance apart and worked backwards to get the width of the final drive gear ( fig 5 page 590, fig 17 and 18 page 873 

martin

Alex Collins04/07/2015 23:00:36
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

Spoke to the Boiler man today. CSME had a members open day.
He is happy with the general construction and soldering. As expected commented that the 2 top bushes were not up to standard.
I need to re flux them and get the solder that is on them to flow. At that point the boiler should be fine.
Spoke in detail and it's obvious to me that my Hearth is not good enough. I should have enough heat with the tools I have but the heat is escaping.

The frame also got favourable comments. Picked up some tips on the motion bars. I need to make them on a jig.

Some great Models on display and running. Guy had his first run in a polly. The grin went full circle.


Alex Collins06/07/2015 18:31:31
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

I now have smooth motion.
Centre Popped a Jig through the frame rails. Ground up a bit of 1/4" silver steel to a point.
Soft soldered the rods (to the jig as well most of the time). Took a few goes to get them right.
Making Bushes to go over 6BA screws (2.6mm ID / 1/8" OD) was not going to be easy. I also think the crush factor as we do up the screws may be rather high.
Drilled the motion rods 4mm and made some shouldered screws.
8mm OD Head. 4 mm shank for the bushes to run in 6BA Thread for the crank arms.

Motion was a tad sticky so drilled the bushes to 4.2mm and all is good.

Wheels all line up but I don't have a suitable track or place to put the track.
The CSME (Chelmsford society of Model engineers) Track will allow me to run between gauges if I shorten the axle bushes.

martin ranson 207/07/2015 13:41:08
avatar
135 forum posts
2 photos

Alex ... a question about your letter above ... does this mean you are using the rails for 2 1/2 and 3 1/2 inch tracks or does it mean you are using the rails for 3 1/2 and 5 inch tracks please ?? if you eventually get your own 32 mm track does it mean the bushes will need to be remade a different length ??

Does it mean you may need some new spacers to hold everything in place along the 2 axles ??

martin

Alex Collins07/07/2015 17:04:35
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

Hi Martin.
The Chelmsford Track has 3 1/2", 5" and 7 1/4" Tracks.
None of these gauges are suitable - they are to wide.

My Thoughts are, with narrower Axle spacers I can move the wheels apart and run on the track between the 5" and 7 1/4" gauges.
I'm aware that running on these rails would be totally unsupported but briefly spoke to a member who has done just that.
I did intend to measure the actual gaps last weekend. I forgot to take a suitable measuring stick.

Maybe my ideas are crazy at times............

Steven Greenhough07/07/2015 17:14:29
144 forum posts
54 photos
Is there not a 1 1/4 inch gap between the 3.5 and 5 inch rail that you can run a 32mm wheelset on?
Alex Collins07/07/2015 18:32:35
avatar
147 forum posts
38 photos

I need to go measure. Until I do that nothing is final....

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Sign up to our Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
cowells
Sarik
MERIDIENNE EXHIBITIONS LTD
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest

 

Donate

donate