Forum sponsored by:

Stuart S50

Search for: in Thread Title in

Andrew Johnston	26/10/2010 10:31:43
7061 forum posts 719 photos	Wolfie, A few random notes: 1) Err, I think John means 1/16" to 1/4" 2) If you can afford it, a 1mm to 6mm by 0.1mm drill set is a good investment, 0.5mm increments are a bit coarse for tapping sizes 3) Don't buy cheap drills 4) Reamers come in two basic types - hand and machine (sometimes called chucking reamers). Hand reamers are tapered along part of their length and are intended to be used by hand with a tap wrench. Machine reamers are parallel and cut on the front edge only, for use under power in a machine tool 5) Metric machine reamers come in 0.01mm increments, sometimes they are cheaper than the imperial equivalents, but sometimes not, so shop around 6) Machine reamers need something to cut on, a few thou for an 1/8" reamer up to 20 thou for more for a 1" reamer 7) As a starting point run a reamer at half the speed and twice the feedrate for the same size drill 8) Never run a reamer backwards, that will destroy the cutting edges Regards, Andrew
Wolfie	26/10/2010 12:23:03
502 forum posts	Excellent reamer info, thanks. "OK the slide valve is like a small block of metal with a recess on the face side. Think of it as a small box shape. The size of the recess is such that it will bridge over two of the ports, eg exhaust and one cylinder port. OK, now, the whole of the valve area is covered by another larger box shape The steam supply is connected to this. The pressure pushes the valve against the valve face, which gives us a seal. " OK thats clear , effectively, the underside of the valve controls the exhaust only, inlet is when the port is open to the steam chest. Great info gang, this is why I joined the forum. Thanks
John Olsen	26/10/2010 20:34:05
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	Yes Andrew, I didn't proof read as well as I might have did I. One plan I used when I was just getting started was that I bought a dedicated drill for each tapping size and also a drill just under the size of each reamer. These are, or were, kept separate and only used for their particular task. That means that you can get by without a full set of metric by tenths, ot a full set of number drills for that matter, and also your tapping drills should be in good condition because they have not been used for other work. To elaborate a little more on the valve, the inside edges of the recess control the exhaust timing, the two outside edges control the inlet timing. These outside edges are usually extended a little so that the valve will slightly more than cover all three ports when in the mid position. (Called lap.) Together with a carefully chosen angle of advance on the eccentric that moves the valve, this gives admission that starts just a tiny bit before the piston reaches the end of its stroke, (lead steam) and the steam supply gets cut off part way down the stroke. (early cutoff.) On a full size engine, starting the admission just before the piston gets to the end helps bring the heavy moving parts to a halt, it also means the valve is open enough to do some good by the time it is needed. It is doubtful if it matters much on a little engine like the S50. Cutting off the steam partway down the stroke saves steam, and we still get useful work from the steam that is already in the cylinder expanding. So we get slightly less power and much better economy. Most of the complication with valve gears is concerned with providing both the capability to reverse the engine, and the capability to change the point in the stroke at which the steam is cut off. This lets us supply steam for most of the stroke when we need the maximum grunt, for instance on a locomotive when starting. When we are up to speed, we can save steam by cutting off early. The S50 will avoid all this complexity by having a single eccentric and no reversing or adjustable cutoff, so when you get to that bit you only have to worry about a couple of things: 1/ The valve itself should be accurately made, eg the total length and the size of the recess. (But nothing that reasonable care cannot provide, we don't need to be too paranoid.) 2/ The correct stroke and the correct angular setting of the eccentric that drives the valve. The angle is usually adjustable by loosening a grub screw. There is an ideal position, but there is a range of settings that will at least work, so you can experiment when you get there. 3/ The setting of the valve on its rod. The travel of the valve over its ports should be equal in both directions. Usually there is a nut in the top of the valve, and the position is adjusted by turning the valve rod around. You can check this setting when everything is assembled except for the cover on the steam chest. But of course you have quite a lot of other bits to make before you need to set the valve. regards John
Wolfie	27/10/2010 13:13:13
502 forum posts	Very informative, I'm beginning to understand a lot more already
Wolfie	27/10/2010 21:38:37
502 forum posts	OK chaps managed to take some pics tonight. Here is my workshop. As you can see its restricted to a bench with a few bits on and a radio permanently tuned to Planet Rock. The cardboard box at left is my spray booth for my other modelling hobby. And my baby lathe, isn't she cute (not) OK my steam engine to date... rear cylinder cover. I have turned the inner part of the inside of it 15 thou too far (radius-wise). Is this likely to be a problem? And the rest of it, piston, piston rod and gland thing. Piston rod is 3/32" too short but I really don't want to make another one (I'll have to make a piston too and I'm running out of brass), is this likely to be crucial?? And finally...... my piece of cast iron chuck key for scale
John Olsen	27/10/2010 22:04:43
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	Hi Wolfie, The slightly smaller register on the cover is not likely to be a very big deal. When you eventually fit it to the cylinder, you will spot through the holes in the cover to start the tapped holes in the cylinder. At that point you can make sure it is lined up nicely on the outside. Speaking of drilling the holes, I don't suppose you have any dividing equipment as such? If you have access to a good printer and a drawing program you can make a template. Print the template out full size, and you can use it to mark out the holes quite accurately. The best way is to turn a metal template with the register the same as the cover on one side and the cylinder on the other. The holes are drilled through the template in tapping size, and it is used to guide the drill on each part in turn. Another way is to drill the cover, but in tapping size only. Use that to set out the tapping size holes in the cylinder, then enlarge the ones in the cover to a clearance size for the screws. With the second way any mistakes are made on the actual cover.... (There are some good free drafting programs available, there is a thread about this on here. An inkjet, or better, a laser printer will give accuracy to about 3 thou or so. ) OK, piston rod length. The important thing here is that the piston must not hit either cover at the end of its stroke. There is usually a bit of room for adjustment here, the rod will screw into the crosshead, often with a lock nut. If there is enough length engaged when you have set the piston to clear about equally at each end of the stroke it will be fine. Usually you want a length about equal to the diameter engaged in the crosshead. By the way, it is usually a good idea to make the bore before making the piston, as it is easier to make a piston to fit a bore than it is to make a bore to fit a piston. regards John
Wolfie	27/10/2010 22:30:33
502 forum posts	Register?? Whats that? Actually theres a tutorial in the ME mag this last few fortnights making a Stuart engine and they make a steel template with which they drill all cylinder holes at one time Yeah I know I've started in an odd spot but I'm restricted to what materials I have handy etc. Can't afford to buy anything new yet (got made redundant, mkes life difficult). I did look to see if I could buy just the cylinder casting from Stuart and its about £10 so might go for that
Weary	27/10/2010 22:57:31
421 forum posts 1 photos	Wolfie, Don't know if you are aware of this, but on 'you tube' there is a complete series of videos showing construction of an oscilating steam engine to one of Tubal Cain's designs. Whilst this is a different engine to the one that you are building many of the procedures are similar. Part II deals with machining the cylinder and end-cover (only one in this case of course). If you want to take a look just go to youtube, and search 'Building a model steam engine', or some similar combination of terms. You will see that there are also quite a few 'show and tell' videos of various kinds listed on the side-bar of similar and related vids. There are also videos of dial gauges etc. being used and set-up if you search 'dial gauges'; though I don't think that there is anything on that particular topic that answers your questions directly. Regards, Phil
Wolfie	27/10/2010 23:14:33
502 forum posts	I wasn't aware of that but will go look at it. Thanks!
John Olsen	27/10/2010 23:54:10
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	A "register" is anything on one part that sticks out so that it can engage with a recess on another part. So the cover has a shallow part that sticks out and engages with the bore, thus locating the cover nicely on the end. This will be more important on the end with the gland, since you want the bore, the gland, and the crosshead to all nicely line up with each other. But even there, it is possible to get it all to the right position and then nip up the screws. (Perfectionists are free to wince here if they wish.) One thing you want to be doing is keeping an eye open around the place for bits and pieces of suitable metal. You will need to learn what you can and can't easily use. Some bits of stuff are hardened and so not so useful. Any brass or bronze you can lay your hands on should be grabbed and treasured. Yes, Harold Halls series should be quite useful to you. There are some good ideas there for templates. It is always better to waste time making a template out of cheap material than waste more by spoiling a good part. Buying the cylinder could be a good plan, also maybe eventually the flywheel since it is quite hard to make a really nice looking flywheel out of solid material. regards John
Wolfie	04/11/2010 12:16:01
502 forum posts	Getting on a bit. I bought the cylinder casting (and also the flywheel while I was at it). Its much smaller than I thought it would be, looks like it could be difficult to hold for machining? If you can find the (free) Dockstadter valve gear program and load it on your machine, you can see live animations of how this all works I downloaded this, looks handy. However I don't know what my particular valve gear is called?? Have made a start on the flywheel. Found it very difficult to get true in chuck. Eventually got more or less true enough to drill although its not perfect. I plan to mount it on a spindle and bolt it on to machine the outside rim.
John Olsen	04/11/2010 20:04:54
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	Hi Wolfie, I don't know if Harold Hall has covered the flywheel or cylinder yet, but it could be worth checking that series for some ideas. I would usually hold the flywheel in the for jaw chuck, setting it up for the best compromise. You want both the boss and the inside of the rim to be running as true as possible. Since the casting may not be absolutely true, you may have to compromise. That lets you then turn one side of the boss, bore the hole, and turn one side of the rim. Then I would turn it around, mount on the faceplate and clamp through the spoke holes. take care not to put too much pressure on the spokes. Use a piece of plywood to space out from the faceplate and set it true by the bore hole. (using that dial gauge) Now you can turn the other face of the boss, the other edge of the rim, and the rim itself. The cylinder may need some work with a file so that the faces are flat enough to sit nicely against the chuck. Small ones can usually be held OK in the four jaw chuck. One point is to do the bore and the face that will be the bottom cover at the same setting. this is so that face is square to the bore, so that when you put the cover on with the gland it will all be lined up nicely . Your gear will be a single eccentric with no reversing . None of the setups that Dockstadter shows (in the copy I have anyway) are a match for that since they are all reversing gears. If you look at the STEP_OUT file and set the gear in either full forward or full reverse, what you will see is pretty much what you would get with a single eccentric gear. There is a little icon about the middle of the row which looks like a pipe with steam coming out, this will turn on a display of steam, red for boiler pressure, purple as it expands, and blue for exhaust. regards John
Stub Mandrel	04/11/2010 20:57:00
4318 forum posts 291 photos 1 articles	I think the S50 has Stephenson valve gear (Yes the same Stephenson as in The Rocket) Neil
Wolfie	04/11/2010 22:25:23
502 forum posts	I held the flywheel by its boss. Its difficult when all the surfaces are rough, to start anywhere. Like I said, I drilled the hole first and will try it that way. Whats a faceplate?
John Olsen	05/11/2010 03:04:10
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	The S 50 is a horizontal mill engine, it will only have a single eccentric. http://www.stuartmodels.com/inprod_det.cfm/section/casting/mod_id/17 Mill engines were intended for driving factory machines, and as such were very rarely if ever fitted with reverse. (If I say never someone will come up with an example.) OK, a faceplate is a flat plate with some slots in it that screws or mounts onto the spindle of the lathe. It is a way of holding jobs that are too big or are the wrong shape to easily fit into a chuck. Since it is flat, it does need one side of the job to be at least moderately flat, and it can be a challenge to find ways of clamping the job to it so that the screws don't get in the way. if you don't have one, it is something to consider possibly making or buying at some point. Making one can be a bit tricky since ideally you would want to attach the blank to the faceplate to turn it, and since the reason you were making one is because you didn't have one.... in some of the smaller lathes, you will get a drive plate, eg the Unimat provides a little aluminium plate that screws on the mandrel and has three slots in it. This is intended as a way to drive a drive dog, which is used when turning between centres. It can be uss a faceplate for light work, but that lathe actually has a much better cast iron T-slotted faceplate available as well. Anyway, so long as the hole you have made is reasonably true to the rest of the casting, all should be well. So next step is to turn a mandrel to fit the hole on a piece of bar held firmly in the chuck, with a thread on the end (which can be cut with a die) and mount the flywheel on that. You will only be able to take quite light cuts, since it may try to turn on the mandrel. You can use loctite to help too. If you made your mandrel out of a fairly large diameter piece of bar, you could consider tapping it near the edge for a screw that would engage with one of the spokes to provide a positive drive. The Stuart cast iron is generally excellent, but it is not unknown with any cast iron to find hard patches on the surface. They will usually not be deep, so if you are having trouble, you can consider a little careful grinding to take the skin off the offending patch. Carbide tools are of course good for this job, if you have them. I should stop thinking of possible problems that p[roably won't happen and let you get on with it. regards John
Wolfie	05/11/2010 09:06:21
502 forum posts	I watched some of that Tubal Cain video last night where he breaks ot the cylinder cast and faces it and the cylinder covers. I am surprised at how little he seems to worry about accuracy, theres me trying to get it down to the last ten thou.... I got some of that glue too. I was advised to get '603', but the best i could find was '601' is there any difference?? Edited By Wolfie on 05/11/2010 09:07:42
Nicholas Farr	05/11/2010 09:57:21
3988 forum posts 1799 photos	Hi Wolfie, I assume you are talking about Loctite 603, which is an improved 601. I doubt that you will notice much difference. You can get all thier technical info from thier website www.loctite.co.uk Regards Nick.
Wolfie	06/11/2010 17:49:32
502 forum posts	HELLPP Whats with this flywheel. Its destroying my lathe tools!!!!
Stub Mandrel	06/11/2010 20:33:26
4318 forum posts 291 photos 1 articles	Possibly chill spots on the outside, they can be glass hard. Invest in a cheap set of tungsten carbide tools - I have a pretty basic set and mainly use them for breaking the skin of tough spots on castings. Stuart have a reputation for good castings without chill spots (though all four corners of the valve face of my 10V were chilled as was the outsiode of the flywheel), they may change the flywheel if it's really bad. Neil
John Olsen	06/11/2010 23:40:29
1294 forum posts 108 photos 1 articles	While I would agree that Stuart do very good castings, I would not agree that they are always without chill spots. However, we also have to remember that Stuart spans a very long period of time, and the ones I have had that were questionable would all be from a long time ago, so should not reflect on current production. They have had a bit of a habit of providing parts that were pretty well at nominal size even before cleaning up...commendably accurate casting but a little bit of machining allowance is always good to have! I think 10V valve chests may at one stage have been a problem for them, I have seen more than one with a blowhole in the area where teh gland boss meets the chest. They do swap faulty castings I beleive, but from 12,000 miles away it is easier to make another from a piece of bar stock. Where I have seen chill on Stuart castings, it has never been very deep. So a careful sesson on the grinder, taking the surface only from the hard spots will generally get you through it to where the ordinary HSS will cope. Otherwise as suggested by Neil, a carbide tool may be your best bet. Chilled spots show up when you are turning as having a silvery appearance compared to the rest of the iron, which should be grey. (Hence "grey cast iron" in specifications) Accuracy... well, it is good to try to work to close tolerances, it is good practice for when you really need to. But mostly these parts want to fit each other nicely, they do not need to be a precise size as such. So if the bore comes out a bit bigger than intended, you just make a piston to suit and so on. This is not how it is (or should be) done in industry, but will be fine for a steam engine. regards john

<< First < Prev 1 2 3 Next > Last >>

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts

*Oct 2023: FORUM MIGRATION TIMELINE*
05/10/2023 07:57:11
Making ER11 collet chuck
05/10/2023 07:56:24
What did you do today? 2023
05/10/2023 07:25:01
Orrery
05/10/2023 06:00:41
Wera hand-tools
05/10/2023 05:47:07
New member
05/10/2023 04:40:11
Problems with external pot on at1 vfd
05/10/2023 00:06:32
Drain plug
04/10/2023 23:36:17
digi phase converter for 10 machines.....
04/10/2023 23:13:48
Winter Storage Of Locomotives
04/10/2023 21:02:11
More Latest Posts...
View All Topics

Support Our Partners

Shopping Partners

Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads

Reeves** - Rebuilt Royal Scot by Martin Evans
by John Broughton
£300.00
BRITANNIA 5" GAUGE James Perrier
by Jon Seabright 1
£2,500.00
Drill Grinder - for restoration
by Nigel Graham 2
£0.00
WARCO WM18 MILLING MACHINE
by Alex Chudley
£1,200.00
MYFORD SUPER 7 LATHE
by Alex Chudley
£2,000.00
More "For Sale" Ads...

Latest "Wanted" Ads

D1-3 backplate
by Michael Horley
Price Not Specified
fixed steady for a Colchester bantam mark1 800
by George Jervis
Price Not Specified
lbsc pansy
by JACK SIDEBOTHAM
Price Not Specified
Pratt Burnerd multifit chuck key.
by Tim Riome
Price Not Specified
BANDSAW BLADE WELDER
by HUGH
Price Not Specified
More "Wanted" Ads...

Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues