By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more
Forum sponsored by:
Forum sponsored by Forum House Ad Zone

Phase Converter Which Type?

Trying to work out what type of phase converter to get

All Topics | Latest Posts

Search for:  in Thread Title in  
John Olsen01/09/2010 10:46:08
1294 forum posts
108 photos
1 articles
Single phase speed controllers are not very likely to happen.  The market would be very small , and it would not be an easy thing to do. The motor would have to be the type with a starting winding, and the invertor would have to be designed with two phases, one suited to the starting winding, which, if it is switched in and out, will have a much lower impedence than the main winding. (so it would really be a two phase controller.) Each motor would need a different solution, so the controller would have to be set up individually. After all that you would still have starting torque that would probably not be as good as the three phase motor
 
Three phase motors, bought new, are actually cheaper, Watt for Watt, than single phase motors, and have better torque characteristics. They are also lighter, which is one of the main things making them cheaper. This does not help of course if you already have the single phase motor. 
 
The trick would be to keep an eye out for suitable surplus three phase motors and see if you can acquire any. I've just put one into service that my Dad scrounged from somewhere about forty years ago...a nice little quarter horsepower unit.
 
regards
John
joegib01/09/2010 12:07:10
154 forum posts
18 photos
Well, the speed control of single phase motors is something model engineers longed for for decades and indeed, there are now single-phase inverters available. But these command a premium price because the overall demand is relatively small. Predominantly, industry wants 3-phase inverters to drive/control 3-phase equipment. To a lesser extent inverters accepting 1-phase input and outputting a 3-phase supply are used in buildings only having a 1-phase supply. They're used, for inststance, to enable sophisticated control of 3-phase fans and pumps (for environmental control) and other industrial processes. In short, the demand for 1-phase inverters is never likely to bring the price down to the level of 3-phase units.
 
On the 'bells and whistles' point, these represent the cheap elements in inverter design. They're just a matter of relatively cheap signal level circuitry plus software (firmware). The expensive elements are the power components — power transistors, rectifiers, heat sinks etc. — capable of handling mains level voltages/currents. So, omitting bells and whistles isn't going to materially affect the manufacturing cost and thus you're unlikely ever to see cheap 1-phase inverters.
 
Nowadays, power provision and control seems to be going in a quite different direction for hobbyist machine tools. Pretty well all Chinese lathes below 10-inch swing now come with a relatively high-power DC motor under Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) control. The only exceptions I know of are older marques of the 9x20 and the Sieg C6. Even the German maker, Wabeco, now supplies DC motors.
 
You talk of 'expensive 3 phase units' but for a given power 3-phase motors are appreciably cheaper than 1-phase units. Indeed, depending on your equipment, you might be able to recover something from your old kit. I've seen the 'must-have-Myford-gear' crowd pay on E-Bay significantly more for a second hand 1-phase, resilient-mount, Crompton-Parkinson motor than I paid for a new 3-phase motor.

Joe
 
 
PS - Oops, I missed John Olsen's post!

Edited By joegib on 01/09/2010 12:09:41

Richard Parsons02/09/2010 15:46:40
avatar
645 forum posts
33 photos
 

I will agree with you on the size of the market. However plans are cheap and easy to sell. Part kits (plans and boards) are not so easy, full kits are a bit more difficult and ready to run even more complex in terms work contents etc. There is a very nice place to trade it is a niche market one which can provide a small company with a nice living.

We are after all Model Engineers (or in my case supposed to be) so putting the thing together should be within our capabilities.
Billy Mills03/09/2010 00:11:54
377 forum posts
Richard
Read your letter "Speed Control" in MEW 168. Firstly you don't need a licence to get 3 phase in the UK. Many homes already have a three phase head where there is a large heating demand e.g. electric underfloor heating or where the consumer has requested 3 phase.  Having  3 phase installed  can be expensive in rural locations but in urban settings may not be that expensive as the 3 phase supply is outside in the street. It is worth enquiring about after  looking under the stairs for 3 large sealed fuseholders above the feed.
 
There seems to be a lot of scare stories of invasive officials, revaluation and visitors from other planets... perhaps it sells more convertors.
 
Your request for a single phase convertor has already been well answered in MEW and in this forum. If you want to run variable speed then go to DC brushless for low speeds or 3 phase for higher torque. Both motors are better than single phase to drive machine tools.
 
Regards,
Alan.
 

 
 
 
 
 

John Olsen03/09/2010 00:55:31
1294 forum posts
108 photos
1 articles
Hi All,
 
I think the original poster was looking for a way to control the speed of  the existing single phase motors. While in principle some degree of control should be possible, I doubt if it is worth the effort. Once the motor is running it should, over at least some speed range, adjust its speed to follow the frequency of the supply from an inverter. However the torque of a single phase motor is not good, so it will tend to drop out at lower speeds. If we use another inverter generated phase on a starting winding we could improve that, but would have to set the second phase up to suit the actual impedence of that winding, which will depend on what type of motor it is.
 
I wouldn't care to try and publish and sell parts for a design of inverter suitable for this sort of application. Power electronics circuits are once properly designed and debugged very reliable, but they are very unforgiving of mistakes. The one I built at university went through 8 output switching devices in the development process, they tended to go in pairs since if one fails to turn off when the other turns on, they form a dead short across the internal DC bus. For a development project that is OK, but you don't want your customers going through devices like that when they try to get your kit going. Fuses are not fast enough to protect this sort of device.
 
I dunno about the UK, but here in New Zealand the main barrier to installing three phase is the sheer cost. It cost about NZ$6000 for a friend of mine when he did it to power a rather large lathe and mill in his home workshop. (probably around GBP2000 or so) That was needed for the size of the machines, there was no way that phase converters could have done the power. But as you will see, for machines up to the power of a single outlet, say 3 hp, an AC motor controller is an attractive proposition.
 
regards
John
 
 
Andrew Johnston03/09/2010 09:37:24
avatar
7061 forum posts
719 photos
My experience in the UK mirrors that mentioned by Alan and John above. I simply rang the electricity company, they sent a man out to do a survey, they quoted a price and you either agree or otherwise. However, the cost is highly dependent upon the location of the existing three phase supply. The total cost to me was £2500. The existing street supply is on the far side of the road to me, and I'm told by a friend in the house building trade that this probably accounted for £1000 of the bill. The reason being that if the electricity companies dig up the road, then they have to gaurantee the repairs for a year. Consequently they bump up the price, just in case their sub-sub-contractors make a mess of it.
 
Although expensive, I think that having the three phase supply installed was worthwhile in comparison to the time wasted in mucking about converting motors from star to delta, buying inverters (this was 10 years ago, so the electronics wasn't as cheap then) and sorting out the contactors, wiring etc. The other factor was that the existing single phase supply was below par, and needed replacing according to the survey report done before I bought the property.
 
I can categorically state that no license is needed, and it is nothing to do with the council. I've never had a visit from revaluation people or aliens. I pay exactly the same per kWh as I would if it was a single phase domestic supply. The house runs on a single phase anyway!
 
Regards,
 
Andrew
John Rudd03/09/2010 12:01:05
1479 forum posts
1 photos
Aidan,
 
I like many others have bought from Drives Direct. I spoke to Dave on the phone, found him very helpful and informative. The motor/vfd package he supplied does the job for me..( Chester 9*20 vfd conversion) I'm really pleased I went that route.
Richard Parsons04/09/2010 14:22:30
avatar
645 forum posts
33 photos
 

In 1975 I went to the local electricity board showroom. It was at lunch time I asked about 3 phase supply (which was hitched to my house from an underground cable which ran under my back garden without any way-leave}. The girl went to a cupboard looked in and came back. “Have you got a licence?” She asked “no” I said.  “You have to have a licence” she retorted. Before I could ask here where do I apply for a licence? She had vanished. I spent the next few years on and off trying to find out where I got a licence. There was no point in trying to go ‘higher up the tree’ as you would never get past the ‘flack stoppers’.

I would like to read MEWS 168 but it is the end of the holidays so I doubt if I will receive it. I may get 169 in October if ‘they’ have been issued with their winter loin cloths and cleft sticks.etc, but 168 I doubt it.

John Olsen many thanks, I understand your points. I may well look into an auxiliary countershaft, but I am writing a set of logical ideas for such an electronic device and the way it should be used. It would have a limited speed range. Yes It would have one relay yes but that is it. There is a company that provides speed controllers for large AC fans

Richard Parsons03/10/2010 16:56:37
avatar
645 forum posts
33 photos
   

Objectives

The speed controller is designed to control the speed of a single phase motor by steps within a limited range by changing the frequency of the power supplied to the motor.

Constraints

The speed controller is subject to the following constraints

It will not be used to start the motor.

It will not output frequencies off more than 45Hz.

It will not output frequencies of less than 20 Hz.

The system will only be used in conjunction with the main ‘forward’ direction switch.

The system is designed to work with SPIMs (Single phase Induction motors). Where the motor has a centrifugal switch the speed controller will disconnect this whilst the motor is running under the control of the speed controller.

It will be designed to be operated in the way described below –see ‘method of use’.

It will be designed to ‘fail soft’.

Pre-requisites

The machine to which the device is connected will have one (or more) of the following. These are to allow the motor to start ‘light’.

A fast and loose pulley system.

A clutch.

A method of using the belt tensioner which allows the belts to slip.

The controls which operate these features will be fitted with a micro switch system which will be closed (passing current) if the motor is free from the machine it is driving (The clutch is open/the ‘fast and loose’ pulley is on loose/the belt tensioner is allowing the belt to slip). If the switch is open circuit (low) then the speed controller is inhibited.   The objective here is to allow the motor to be started using the normal 50 Hz supply.

The method of use

In use the motor would be started normally. If the motor is disconnected from the machine it is driving then the speed controller would become available. To use the speed controller the operator would select the speed required by turning a Yaxley/Rotoplex switch and press the start button. There would then be a small delay, which is designed to allow the motor’s starting surge to finish before speed control unit is called after starting the motor. The motor would then be disconnected from the main 50 Hz supply and a few milliseconds later switched over to the lower frequencies supplied by the speed controller. This procedure would be have to be followed each time the motor was stopped hence the need for the motor disconnecting mechanism.

How would it work?

Most of the answers I have read both here and in MEWS refer to digital solutions, but there are older (non digital ways) which do not need programming. They are ‘hard wired’ to do the job. When turning with a standard (belt driven or gear headed) lathe the turner selects the nearest appropriate speed and adjusts the feed accordingly.

The unit comprises 5 main assemblies which are : -

The Oscillator which out puts a pure sinusoid. The frequencies output are controlled by had wired components, which are selected by a rotary switch of the Yaxley type.

The power amplifiers which amplifies the input sinusoid from the oscillator and drives the motor.

The control relay/timer which controls the event sequence. I think such relays are still made as it is still necessary to start a 3 phase motor as ‘star’ and switch to ‘delta for running This may not be necessary if one uses a modified form of ‘drum starter’ which controls the change over from full mains power to power from the speed controller. The drum starter would be locked in the mains supply position if the clutch switch showed that the clutch was ‘engaged’.

For those motors with a centrifugal switches there would need to be a mechanism which would isolate the centrifugal switch when the speed controller was in use.

A no-volt release which will isolate the speed controller unit when the ‘forward direction run switch’ is turned off. 

With my limited knowledge of electronics, but long ago and far away I built a superhetrodyne radio with push button control for my granny. Oh yes it worked

Edited By Richard Parsons on 03/10/2010 17:10:58

geoff28/11/2010 18:34:03
29 forum posts
this may or may not be obvious to all users of invertors but unless they are installed in the machines electrical enclosure they require an enclosure to house them to prevent contamination from swarf or metal filings or from direct contact with the supply or output voltages to the user which has been described in the iee regulations as having an ip protection value if you have a copy see setting up a home workshop autumn 2008 pages 46 47 & 48
John Coates09/01/2011 20:26:00
avatar
558 forum posts
28 photos
Posted by John Coates on 24/08/2010 12:24:17:
A really useful thread btw folks as I plan to change my lathe and mill to 3 phase for the variable speed at some time in the future so this is great for my research
 

Which I've just completed and variable speed is fantastic 

Got a 1hp inverter from Drives Direct for £77 (ebay) then a 1hp motor  for £69 (ebay) and just finished wiring it all up today
 
And it's so much quieter so will be able to be in the garage without annoying wifey or neighbours. No more whining speed wheels
 
Got a remote control pod to wire in but wanted to check it all worked properly 

All Topics | Latest Posts

Please login to post a reply.

Magazine Locator

Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!

Find Model Engineer & Model Engineers' Workshop

Sign up to our Newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.

You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy

Latest Forum Posts
Support Our Partners
cowells
Sarik
MERIDIENNE EXHIBITIONS LTD
Subscription Offer

Latest "For Sale" Ads
Latest "Wanted" Ads
Get In Touch!

Do you want to contact the Model Engineer and Model Engineers' Workshop team?

You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.

Click THIS LINK for full contact details.

For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.

Digital Back Issues

Social Media online

'Like' us on Facebook
Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter
 Twitter Logo

Pin us on Pinterest

 

Donate

donate