What is the process mentioned in ME Postbag 4467?
Jerry Wray | 14/12/2013 18:58:34 |
84 forum posts 4 photos | Posted by Clive Foster on 19/10/2013 16:06:50:
Nothing very remarkable there. Basic carbon pack case hardening without accelerant but preceded by an etching step which, presumably has a similar effect to an accelerant in increasing the speed and depth of carbon penetration. Sodium nitrite quenching is an established practice said to reduce the chances of cracking and distortion as compared to plain water whilst improving steel properties. So, in principle, no different from all the other nostrums in the carbon, additives in the quench versions. Far as I can see all variations do what is said on the tin if you do it right but the structural variation of steel is incredibly complex in detail so there is much to be gained if you get the process control right. In the home shop simple, repeatable and tolerance of ahem "variable" process control is much more important than uber high performance. Skimming the book Mr Stevens seems a less than reliable source. Basically reporting what he has been told, what sounds right and so on. Daily Mail science at best. The official document quote should not be taken at face value either. Much face covering, position protecting and politics going on as the folk who approved the final text certainly did not understand the technologies and the implications. In my experience getting accurate technical assessments through the military support 'crats is nigh on impossible! Clive Has Clive considered the conditions under which much of this technology was gathered? WWII had just ended, the Allies scoured the defeated Axis caches of documents to garner as much information as they could. You will be aware that the '4 Powers' kept their finds to themselves. The searchers worked in closely guarded secrecy, always with the fear of the Soviets who could have taken possession of everything found in Eastern Germany, which at that time included Berlin. I have been privileged to have seen some of the material gathered in its original form in my area of experience, before it was publicly available. Although the general direction of development was similar to that of the Allies some of the detail was novel and found later to be of value to us. We should not run away with the thought that that Britain and America were far ahead at that time, After all the Germans might have developed 'the Bomb' first had it not been for the destruction of the heavy water plant in Norway. JerryNotts |
robjon44 | 08/03/2014 09:28:57 |
157 forum posts | Muzzer, I conducted the very same experiment during my schooldays near 60 years ago, a couple of miles from home was limestone pit (marl pit) being used for landfill. We visited regularly as there was no telling what might turn up that could be incorporated into one of our "projects" & also prime rat shooting territory. Same story, brand new 50 gallon drum, stand upright, add water, tighten plug, big bonfire, retire to discreet distance behind very large rocky boulders, Albert himself is credited with saying " If i knew what I was doing, I wouldnt call it research". Ends dome, collosal explosion, as steam condenses the drum is sucked completely flat from top to bottom, end exits edgeways & climbs vertically about 300 feet then levels of & glides about 400 yards across a ploughed field, impressive! We conducted a lot of our "chemical" experiments there, as there was plenty of cover (from shrapnel) & it truly was the middle of nowhere. To get back on thread, we did Woodwork & Metalwork in those days (yes, that long ago) as we had a whole country to rebuild, some of the small hand tools I made then, screwdriver blade, small adjustable spanner, depth gauge etc had parts that where hardened with Kasenit & have survived in my toolbox to this day still in use. Bob H |
Please login to post a reply.
Want the latest issue of Model Engineer or Model Engineers' Workshop? Use our magazine locator links to find your nearest stockist!
Sign up to our newsletter and get a free digital issue.
You can unsubscribe at anytime. View our privacy policy at www.mortons.co.uk/privacy
You can contact us by phone, mail or email about the magazines including becoming a contributor, submitting reader's letters or making queries about articles. You can also get in touch about this website, advertising or other general issues.
Click THIS LINK for full contact details.
For subscription issues please see THIS LINK.